Categories
Blog

Whether Private Equity Funds are a Trade or Business

Only “trades or business” under common control are
treated as part of an ERISA controlled group. 
Neither ERISA nor the Treasury regulations define “trade or
business.”  Courts have generally adopted
the standard articulated in Commissioner v. Groetzinger, where the Supreme
Court held that in the context of IRC § 162: “to be engaged in a trade or
business, the taxpayer must be involved in the activity with continuity and
regularity and that the taxpayer’s primary purpose for engaging in the activity
must be for income or profit.  Sporadic
activity, a hobby, or an amusement diversion does not qualify.” 
480 U.S. 23, 35, 107 S.Ct. 980, 987, 94 L.Ed.2d
25 (1987). 
With regard to private equity funds many practitioners
have taken the view that since they are passive investment vehicles with no
employees and no involvement in day-to-day operations, they are not trades or
businesses, and the portfolio companies owned by a private equity fund would
not be in the same ERISA controlled group. 
However, a 2007 PBGC Appeals Board ruling held that a private equity
fund was a trade or business, because it was engaged in an activity with the
primary purpose of income or profit and conducted business through an agent
(the general partner) who managed fund investments on a regular basis.  PBGC Appeals Board Opinion dated Sept. 26, 2007, http://www.pbgc.gov/prac/appeals-board/appeals-decisions.html (a private equity fund
is a “trade or business” under the standard set forth in Comm’r v. Goetzinger,
480 U.S. 23 (1987) that “trade or business” depends on (i) whether the taxpayer
is engaged in an activity with the primary purpose of income or profit, and
(ii) whether the act is conducted with continuity and regularity; in the fact of
the letter that the private equity fund engaged in an activity with the primary
purpose of income or profit and it conducted its business through an agent who
managed the fund’s investments on a regular basis; the private equity fund was
therefore in the same controlled group as its bankrupt portfolio company that
sponsored a pension plan).  According to this ruling, 80%-owned portfolio
companies of a private equity fund may be in the same ERISA controlled
group.  In the rare case that the facts
and circumstances indicate that the private equity fund does not meet the
Groetzinger standard, it would not be part of the controlled group.  (See ABA JCEB Q & As for PBGC (May 2008), Q
& A 11, that in unusual circumstances that the fund is not a trade or
business, it would not be in the controlled group.) 
A 2010 district court in the Sixth Circuit found the
2007 PBGC Appeals Board Opinion to be persuasive.  Board of Trustees, Sheet Metal Workers
National Pension Fund v. Palladium Equity Partners, LLC, 722 F. Supp. 2d 854
(E.D. Mich. 2010) (genuine issue of material fact existed as to whether three
Palladium limited partnerships and Palladium Equity Partners, LLC which served
as advisor (the Palladium funds) were an ERISA controlled group parent liable
for ERISA multiemployer withdrawal liability of the Haden group of companies:
court found 2007 PBGC Appeals Board Opinion to be persuasive that although
investment alone is not a trade or business, “investment plus” where
there is investment advisory and management services by the fund for the
benefit of its partners and there is compensation for the investment advisory
and management services would constitute a trade or business; court found there
was a genuine issue of material fact as to whether the Palladium funds had a
business purpose other than merely investment; the Palladium funds joined their
investments to exert power over financial and managerial activities of the
portfolio companies, selected five of the seven board members and set up
several committees to control the internal operations of the portfolio
companies; there was also general issue of material fact regarding alter-ego
liability). 
Likewise, a 2012 First Circuit case overturned the district
court and found the PBGC Appeals Board Opinion to be persuasive.  Sun Capital Partners III, L.P. v. New England
Teamsters and Trucking Industry Pension Fund, __ F.3d. __, 2013 WL 3814984 (1st.
Cir. July 24, 2013) (two private equity funds managed by Sun Capital owned 70%
and 30% of Scott Brass, Inc. which withdrew from a multiemployer pension plan
prior to filing for bankruptcy; the district court at 903 F.Supp.2d 107 (D. Mass.
2012), had granted the Sun Capital Partners equity funds motion to dismiss
since the private equity funds were passive investors and not a trade or
business  and the 2007 PBGC Appeals Board
Opinion was found by the district court to be unpersuasive because activity of
the general partner should not have been attributed to the investment fund and
continuity and regularity of an activity should not be found merely based on
the size of the investment and profitability; however, the First Circuit
overturned the district court ruling regarding the funds being a “trade or
business” and held that at least the larger of the two Sun funds was engaged in
a trade or business since there was more than mere passive investment, noting
that the funds sought out potential portfolio companies that were in need of
extensive management intervention, indirect management and consulting fees were
provided, the funds had the power to appoint a majority of board members, and the
general partners had authority regarding hiring, firing and compensation which
could be attributed at least to the larger of the two funds through limited
partnership agreements;  both the
district court and the circuit court found in regard to Sun Capital funds that
the purchase of Scott Brass, Inc. in a 70%-30% split was not done with a
principal purpose to evade or avoid liability under ERISA § 4212(c), according
to the district court because there were 
legitimate business reasons for the investment ownership in order to
decrease investment risk for each fund  and according to the First Circuit because
disregarding a 70%-30% split would leave zero ownership; the First Circuit remanded
the case to the district court to determine if there was common control by the
70%-30% ownership (for example if the joint venture is seen as common
ownership)).
 Nevertheless, to avoid any doubt
it may be advisable to specify in agreements with representations about
controlled group members that representations are (or are not) made with regard
to private equity investors and other portfolio companies.

Categories
Blog

RULES RELATING TO 401(K) FEE DISCLOSURE OR INVESTMENT ADVICE GUIDANCE

See June 2012 for updated memo
Categories
Blog

2012 Cost-of-Living Adjustments for Pension Plan and Other Limits

2012 Cost-of-Living Adjustments for Pension Plan and Other Limits
1.   2012 COLA Adjustments for Pension Plan Limits.  The IRS announced in IR-2011-103 http://www.irs.gov/newsroom/article/0,,id=248482,00.html the pension plan limits for 2012 adjusted by IRC § 415(d).  
Pension Plan Limits Adjusted by IRC § 415(d)

2012 Amounts
2011 Amounts
(& 2010 & 2009)
Annual benefits limit for defined benefit plans – Code § 415 (b)
$200,000
$195,000
Annual contributions limit for defined contribution plans – Code § 415(c)
$50,000
$49,000
Elective deferral max for 401(k), 403(b) & 457(b) plans – Code § 402(g)
$17,000
$16,500
Age 50 catch-up contributions – Code § 414(v)
$5,500
$5,500
Age 50 catch-up for SIMPLE Plans (unchanged)
$2,500
$2,500
Elective deferral limit for SIMPLE plans – Code § 408(p)
$11,500
$11,500
Highly-compensated employee threshold – Code § 414(q)
$115,000
$110,000
Annual compensation limit – Code § 401(a)(17)
$250,000
$245,000
Key-employee threshold for top heavy plan – § 416(i)
$165,000
$160,000
ESOP account balance for 5-year / 1-year distribution rule under IRC § 409(o)(1)(C)(ii)
$1,015,000 &
$200,000
$985,000 &
$195,000
The following pension-related amounts adjusted under IRC § 1(f)(3) have been increased:

Pension-Related Amounts Adjusted under § 1(f)(3)

2012 Amount

2011 Amount
Phase-out for deductions for IRA for married couples filing jointly, in which the spouse who makes the IRA contribution is an active participant in an employer-sponsored retirement plan
$92,000 to
$112,000
$90,000  to
$110,000
Adjusted gross income (AGI) phase-out range for married joint filers taxpayers making contributions to a Roth IRA
$173,000 and
$183,000
$169,000 to
$179,000
AGI limit for retirement savings contributions credit for married couples filing jointly
$57,500
$56,500
IRC § 430(c)(7)(D)(i)(II) amount for determining excess employee compensation for defined benefit plans where election has been made
$1,039,000
$1,014,000
2.   2012 Health Savings Account (HSA) Contribution Limits.  As announced in June in Rev. Proc. 2011-32, health savings account (HSA) contribution limits for 2012 will be a maximum single contribution limit of $3,100 and a maximum family contribution limit of $6,250, (up from $3,050 and $6,150 in 2011).
3.   PBGC Maximum Insurance Benefit and PBGC Premiums.  The PBGC maximum insurance benefit for 2011 is $54,000 per year ($4,500 per month).  The PBGC has not yet announced 2012 maximum insurance benefit.
The PBGC flat-rate premium for 2012 is unchanged at $35 for a single-employer plan and $9 for multiemployer plans.  PBGC What’s New for Practitioners – Oct. 25, 2011.
4.   Social Security Taxable Wage Base.  The Social Security Administration announced in a press release http://www.ssa.gov/pressoffice/pr/2012cola-pr.html and fact sheet http://www.ssa.gov/pressoffice/factsheets/colafacts2012.htm , issued October 19, 2011, that there will be a cost-of-living adjustment for Social Security benefits in 2012 of  3.6 percent.  The social security taxable wage base (subject to the 6.2% social security tax) is increased to $110,100 for 2012 (up from $106,800 in 2011).  Also, the annual earnings test is $14,640 for 2012 (up from $14,160 in 2011) prior to normal retirement and $38,880 for 2012 (up from $37,680 in 2011) at normal retirement age.
5.   Transit Passes and Van Pooling Goes Down to $125.  The cost-of-living adjustment for qualified transportation limits under Code § 132(f) had been adjusted in Rev. Proc. 2011-52, for 2012 at $240 for qualified parking benefits and $125 for transit passes and van pooling.  The American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 and the Tax Relief, Unemployment Insurance Reauthorization and Job Creation Act of 2010 provided for temporary parity between public transit/van-pooling and parking, so that the monthly limitation for transit passes and van pooling was the same as for qualified parking benefits – $230 – through December 31, 2011.  But this has thus far not been extended.

       
Categories
Blog

RULES RELATING TO 401(K) FEE DISCLOSURE OR INVESTMENT ADVICE GUIDANCE

9/26/11
RULES RELATING TO 401(K) FEE DISCLOSURE OR INVESTMENT ADVICE GUIDANCE
Categories
Blog

To Grandfather or Not to Grandfather Under the Affordable Care Act

March 7, 2011
TO GRANDFATHER OR NOT TO GRANDFATHER
UNDER THE AFFORDABLE CARE ACT
The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010 (“PPACA”) § 1251 as amended by the Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010 (the “Reconciliation Act”, and collectively the “Affordable Care Act”) § 2301, provide that plans in effect on March 23, 2010 (date of enactment of PPACA) are grandfathered and thereby exempt from some but not all of the requirements of the Affordable Care Act.
v  Many companies are attempting to keep their health plans grandfathered – at least for the time being. (See, e.g. 38 BNA Pension and Benefits Reporter 114 (Jan, 18, 2011) citing survey by the Congressional Research Service that numerous comments to grandfather regulations show a desire of many companies to keep their health plans grandfathered.)

Determination of Grandfathered Status. Treasury Regulation § 54.9815-1251T (with corresponding DOL and HHS regulations), as finalized in 75 Fed. Reg. 34538 (June 17, 2010) and as amended in 75 Fed. Reg. 70114 (Nov. 17, 2010), provides the following rules for determining if the health plan coverage is grandfathered.
(i)  The health coverage must have been in existence on March 23, 2010. Treas. Reg. § 54.9815-1251T(a)(l)(i).
 (ii)  As provided  in the  amended regulations, which are effective as of  Nov. 15, 2010, health insurance coverage does not cease to be grandfathered  merely because a new contract is entered into after March 23, 2010 (for example, a new insurer or a new contract with the existing insurer).  Treas. Reg. § 54.9815-1251T(a)(i) & (ii) as amended in 75 Fed. Reg. 70114 (Nov. 17, 2010).
(iii)  The grandfathered rules apply separately for each benefit package, so that one benefit package under the plan may be grandfathered even if other benefit packages are not. § 54.9815-1251T(a)(i)(i).
(iv)  The plan materials (e.g. the SPD) must contain a statement (see model language in regulations) that the plan administer believes that it is a grandfathered plan.  § 54.9815-1251T (a)(2).
(v)  The plan must maintain records (which must be made available on request) which show the coverage as in effect March 23, 2010. Under the November 17, 2010, amendments to the regulations, if there is a new policy, the new insurer must be given the prior plan terms (including benefits, cost sharing, employer contributions and annual limit) so that it can determine if the plan is still grandfathered. Treas. Reg. § 54.9815-1251T(a)(3), as amended in 75 Fed. Reg. 70114 (Nov. 17, 2010).
v  Note that grandfathering applies even to new employees and family members who join the plan after March 23, 2010.  § 54.9815-1251T(b)(1).
 (vi)  Under anti-abuse rules: (a) if a merger or acquisition is made merely to cover new employees   under a grandfathered plan it will lose grandfathering; and (b) if employees are transferred from the grandfathered plan to a non-grandfathered plan it will cause loss of grandfathered status. § 54.9815-1251T(b)(2).

Maintenance of Grandfathered Status. The following rules apply regarding maintenance of grandfather status and when change to the terms of a plan will cause loss of grandfathered status:
(i)  A reduction in scope of benefits, for example, where benefits to treat a particular condition are eliminated, will cause a loss of grandfathered status. Treas. Reg. § 54.9815.1251T(g)(1)(i).
(ii)  An increase in the percentage of cost-sharing (co-insurance) will cause loss of grandfather statues.  § 54.9815-1251-(g)(1)(ii).
v  Note that an increase in the amount of co-insurance without an increase in percentage of cost sharing will not cause loss of grandfathering.
(iii)  An increase in the fixed cost-sharing amount, i.e. the deductible or out-of-pocket limit, will cause loss of grandfathered status if such increase is more than 15% plus medical inflation above the March 23, 2010 amounts.  § 54.9815-1251T(g)(1)(iii).
(iv)  An increase in the fixed-amount copayment that exceeds the March 23, 2010 copayment amount by the greater of (a) $5 increased by medical inflation or (b) the medical inflation percentage plus 15% will cause loss of grandfathering. § 54.9815-1251T(g)(1)(iv).
(v)  A decrease in the employer contribution rate for premiums based on cost of coverage (i.e., the employer contribution as percentage of total cost of coverage) or based on a formula, by more than 5% below the contribution rate on March 23, 2010 will cause loss of grandfathering. § 54.9815-1251T(g)(1)(v).
(vi)  Changes in annual limit, including (a) the addition of an annual limit where there was none, (b) a decrease in annual limit or at a dollar amount lower than the overall lifetime limit in effect, or (c) decrease in the annual limit for a plan that had a higher annual limit, will cause loss of grandfathering. § 54.9815-1251T(g)(1)(vi).

Transition Rules for Grandfathering.  The following transition rules apply:
    (i)  If there are changes to plans that were effective after March 23, 2010 but such changes were pursuant to a legally binding contract, pursuant to a filing with a state insurance department prior to March 23, 2010, or pursuant to written amendments that were made prior to March 23, 2010, the health insurance will remain grandfathered under transition rules. Treas. Reg. § 54.9815-1251T(g)(2)(i).
    (ii)  If changes are made to the health insurance after enactment of PPACA (March 23, 2010) and prior to adoption of these regulations (June 14, 2010) but the changes are reversed for plan years beginning on or after Sept. 23, 2010, the grandfather will be retained.  § 54.9815-1251T(g)(2)(ii).
    (iii) Where good faith reasonable interpretation of the grandfather requirements prior to issuance of the regulations (June 14, 2010) only modestly exceed the changes permitted by the regulations, the grandfather can be retained. Preamble to final regulation 75 Fed. Reg. 34538, 34569 (June 17, 2010).

       Provisions Not Effective in 2010 if Plans are Grandfathered.  Provisions of the Affordable Care Act that become effective for plan years beginning on or after Sept. 23, 2010 only if the plan is not grandfathered include:
(i) new procedures for claims, appeals and external review under the Public Health Service Act (“PHSA”) § 2719, which is not applicable to grandfathered plans;
(ii) coverage of preventive care without any deductibles, e.g., immunizations or screenings, under PHSA § 2713, which is not applicable to grandfathered plans; 
(iii) prohibition on discrimination in favor of highly-compensated individuals even for insured plans under PHSA § 2716 (Code § 105(h) expanded beyond just self-insured plans), which is not applicable to grandfathered plans;  and
(iv) right to select a participating primary care provider or pediatrician, and to see an obstetrician without referral under PHSA § 2719A, which is not applicable to grandfathered plans.

Provisions Already Effective Even for Grandfathered Plans.   Provisions of the Affordable Care Act that become effective for plan years beginning on or after Sept. 23, 2010 even for grandfathered plans include: 
(i) prohibition on preexisting condition exclusion or discrimination based on health status for children under age 19 under PHSA § 2714, which for group health plans applies even to grandfathered plans;  
(ii) prohibition on rescissions after coverage begins except in the case of fraud or intentional misrepresentation under PHSA § 2712, which applies even to grandfathered plans; and
(iii) restriction on annual limits for group health plans or lifetime limits under PHSA § 2711, which applies even to grandfathered plans.

IRS Circular 230 Disclosure: To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the IRS, we inform you that any U.S. Federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction or matter that is contained in this document.
Categories
Blog

Leased Employees and Employee Classification


Charles C. Shulman, Esq., LLC
Employee Benefits, Employment & Executive Compensation Law
www.ebeclaw.com

 

As published in 36 Journal of Pension Planning & Compliance 21 (Winter 2010)

with minor additions – December 2010

Leased Employees and Employee Classification
Charles C. Shulman
Charles C. Shulman, Esq. has over 20 years of experience in ERISA, employee benefits and executive compensation law. Before starting his own firm, Charlie practiced at Paul Weiss, at Cahill Gordon & Reindel and at Skadden Arps. He is admitted in New York and New Jersey, and may be reached at cshulman@ebeclaw.com, 212-380-3834 or 201-357-0577.
An issue that has recently attracted attention has been misclassification of employees as independent contractors. Government agencies are auditing companies for worker misclassification. Leased employees from professional employer organizations (PEOs) are also subject to examination as to whether the leased employees are really employees of the client companies—with the client companies being either co-employers with the PEO or being the sole employer. This article reviews the state of the law of leased employees and what can be done to minimize any liabilities. The following issues are discussed: (i) examination of PEOs for worker misclassification; (ii) joint employment by client company and PEO or employees of just of the client company; (iii) main criteria for employee status, including under the Darden  test whether the company has the right to control manner and means by which work is accomplished, or the criteria under the economic realities test; (iv) a 2002 revenue procedure with IRS presumption that employees of PEOs should be treated as being the employees solely of the client companies; (v) Section 530 of the Revenue Act of 1978—safe harbor where there was a reasonable basis for worker classification; (vi) whether workers are leased employees as defined in IRC § 414(n)—and impact of leased employee status on testing; (vii) Microsoft “inoculation” language; (viii) cases re worker classification in leasing organizations; and (ix) consequences of misclassification.
Much attention has been focused recently on misclassification of employees as independent contractors. A number of federal and state agencies are auditing and investigating companies for worker misclassification. To some extent, leased employees from leasing companies—often referred to as professional employer organizations (“PEOs”)[1] —are also being examined as to whether the leased employees are actually employees solely of the client companies or are employees of both the PEOs and the client companies.
The main test for employee status is whether the company has the right to control manner and means by which work is accomplished, although other factors also play a role. A 2002 revenue procedure shows an IRS presumption that employees of professional employer organizations may really be the employees solely of the client companies.
Sometimes a PEO and client company will be found to be co-employers, in which case the impact on payroll tax should not be significant since the PEO already collected the payroll tax. Other times, however, the client company may be found to be the sole employer, in which case the amount of payroll tax already collected was not from the employer and could be collected (with penalties) from the true employer (although presumably by the nonemployer could file for a refund).
Even if leased employees are not found to be common-law employees of the recipient company, if they are leased employees as defined in IRC § 414(n), they would also have to be aggregated for nondiscrimination coverage testing (but not for nondiscrimination in contributions or benefits, assuming the plans exclude leased employees). Leased employee under § 414(n) would include where services are provided pursuant to agreement, person has performed such services for the service recipient on a substantially full-time basis for a period of at least one year, and the services are performed under the primary direction or control of the service recipient.
Consequences of misclassification could include payment for retroactive FICA, FUTA, state unemployment and workers compensation if the leased employees are found to be employees only of the client company and not of the leasing company. Overtime pay may be required if the reclassified employee is non-exempt. Retroactive union benefits may be required where applicable. In terms of having to retroactively include reclassified employees in the client companies’ employee benefit plans, this can often be avoided by specifically excluding reclassified employees from retroactive inclusion in the plan. If determined to be leased employees as defined in § 414(n), the company would have to retroactively test its qualified plans for nondiscrimination coverage, although leased employees would not have been included in the plans, assuming the plans exclude leased employees .
See detailed discussion below.
1. Increased Focus on Employee Classification
Crackdown on Employees Misclassified as Independent Contractors
Over the last few years there has been increased focus on employees misclassified as independent contractors. The IRS has increased its audit activity and has also announced that it would conduct audits of 6,000 randomly selected companies in 2010.[2] President Obama’s fiscal year 2011 budget allocated almost $25 million for IRS and DOL audits and enforcement regarding misclassified workers.
New York established in 2007 a Joint Enforcement Task Force on Employee Misclassification coordinating efforts between six agencies, and has uncovered in its first 16 months approximately $157 million in unreported earnings, $5 million in unemployment taxes, $12 million in unpaid wages and in excess of $1 million in workers’ compensation.[3]
Leasing Organization (PEO) and Client Company May Be Reclassified as Joint Employers or Client Company Alone May Be the Employer
Most of the audit activity is focused on workers classified as independent contractors, as this involves significant revenue because of the loss with respect to independent contractors of social security/Medicare tax, unemployment tax, state workers’ compensation, overtime payments, etc. For workers employed by leasing organizations, the above taxes and expenses will presumably have already been paid by the leasing organization. Thus, even if determined that the recipient company is a co-employer with the leasing company there would not be significant liability, since the leasing organization as employer has presumably already withheld income tax and paying FICA, FUTA, state unemployment and workers compensation.[4] However, even in a leased employee context, the workers may be losing out on benefits (unless misclassified employees are specifically excluded from benefits in all events) and the workers may be unfairly excluded from joining or forming a union at the recipient company.
In certain instances, however, worksite/leased employees will be reclassified as employees solely of the recipient company and not of the leasing organization at all.[5] In such cases the government may seek payment with interest and penalties from the real employer, with the leasing organization required to file for refund of such payments.
2. Reclassification as Employee – “Darden” Standard; Microsoft Case
“Darden” Standard—Common-Law Definition for ERISA—Right to Control Manner and Means by Which Work Is Accomplished
The Supreme Court in Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co. v. Darden,[6] has ruled that for purposes of ERISA employee is defined as a “common-law” employee, and that “[i]n determining whether a hired party is an employee under the general common law of agency, we consider the hiring party’s right to control the manner and means by which the product is accomplished.”
The Court lists the following other factors that are also relevant to this inquiry including: (1) the skills required; (2) the source of the instrumentalities and tools; (3) the location of the work; the duration of the relationship between the parties; (4) whether the hiring party has the right to assign additional projects to the hired party; (5) the extent of the hired party’s discretion over when and how long to work; (6) the method of payment; (7) the hired party’s role in hiring and paying assistants; (8) whether the work is part of the regular business of the hiring party; (9) whether the hiring party is in business; (10) the provision of employee benefits; and (11) the tax treatment of the hired party.[7] Thus, one must examine an arrangement primarily to see that the recipient company does not control or have the right to control the manner and means by which the work is accomplished. The other factors listed are not dispositive, but should be evaluated to see if the contemplated arrangement will have favorable or unfavorable factors.[8]
Common-Law Definition Also Adopted in Payroll Tax Regulations
See Treas. Reg. § 1.3121(d)-1(c) which applies the Darden standard, as well as other factors to FICA (Social Security/Medicare) tax. It provides:
(1) Every individual is an employee if under the usual common law rules the relationship between him and the person for whom he performs services is the legal relationship of employer and employee. (2) Generally such relationship exists when the person for whom services are performed has the right to control and direct the individual who performs the services, not only as to the result to be accomplished by the work but also as to the details and means by which that result is accomplished. That is, an employee is subject to the will and control of the employer not only as to what shall be done but how it shall be done. In this connection, it is not necessary that the employer actually direct or control the manner in which the services are performed; it is sufficient if he has the right to do so. … Other factors characteristic of an employer, but not necessarily present in every case, are the furnishing of tools and the furnishing of a place to work, to the individual who performs the services. (Emphasis added)[9]
20 Factors in Rev. Rul. 87-41 Which Has Been Combined Into Three Categories
The IRS in Rev. Rul. 87-41, regarding payroll tax, provides twenty factors that have been identified in rulings or cases as indicating whether sufficient control is present to establish an employer-employee relationship, including: whether an employee must comply with instructions about when, where and how to work; training; integration of the person’s services into the business operation; services rendered personally; hiring, supervising and payment of assistants; continuing relationship; set hours of work; full time requirement; doing work on the premises; order or sequence set by employer; oral or written reports; payment by hour, week, or month; reimbursement of business or travel expenses; furnishing of tools; significant investment; realization of profit or loss; not working for more than one employer; services not available to the general public; right to discharge; and right to quit.
These twenty factors have been broken down in IRS guidance to three categories: behavioral control (whether there is a right to direct or control how the worker does the work, i.e., receiving extensive instructions on how work is to be done and training about required procedures and methods), financial control (whether there is a right to direct or control the business part of the work—having significant investment in the work, not being reimbursed for business expenses and ability to realize a profit or incur a loss all point to being an independent contractor) and relationship between parties (what does the contract say; are there employee benefits).[10]
If the worker classification is unclear, Form SS-8, Determination of Worker Status for Purposes of Federal Employment Taxes and Income Tax Withholding can be filed with the IRS.[11]
Section 530 of the Revenue Act of 1978 Relief—Where Reasonable Basis for Worker Classification
Section 530 of the Revenue Act of 1978, as amended[12] provides an employer with relief from Federal employment taxes with respect to workers who have been reclassified as employees, if (1) the employer has consistently treated similar workers as independent contractors, (2) there was a reasonable basis for doing so, and (3) federal tax returns including Form 1099s are consistent with such treatment.[13]  Reasonable basis requires reasonable reliance on case-law, prior audits and industry standard.
On audit the IRS will often challenge whether there really was reasonable basis for the classification and will examine closely to see if Form 1099s were filed and whether similar workers were always treated the same.[14] Also, an audit of employee classification can lead to an expanded IRS audit of other issues with the employer.
Section 530 is not directly applicable to leased employees, but it does show a Congressional intent to not reclassify employees who are classified on a reasonable basis, and this can apply to leased employees as well.
Vizcaino v. Microsoft—Employees Reclassified Will Require Retroactive Benefits Unless Have Microsoft Inoculation” Language in Plans
One of the major risks of employee misclassification is that the employee may be retroactively entitled to employee benefits. In Vizcaino v. Microsoft,[15] , the Ninth Circuit held that freelancers at Microsoft who were found by the IRS to be misclassified as independent contractors but were in fact common-law employees, and were therefore entitled to benefits under the company’s retirement savings plan, employee stock purchase plan and stock option plan which were provided to all “employees.”[16]
In light of this Ninth Circuit case, recently plans have added “Microsoft inoculation” provisions which state that persons originally classified by the company as independent contractors are not eligible under the plan even if later reclassified by the IRS, until the date of the reclassification determination. Similarly, with regard to leased employees. The client company plans should specifically exclude leased employees from participation even if they are aggregated for nondiscrimination coverage testing purposes.
4.   Case-Law and Rulings Regarding Professional Employer Organizations
Ninth Circuit Case—Where PEO Exerts Only Illusory Control over Leased Employees They Are Not PEO’s Employees and Cannot Remain in its Plan
In Professional & Executive Leasing, Inc. v. Commissioner,[17] the Ninth Circuit ruled that where a leasing company hired employees, covered the employees under the leasing company’s benefit plans and leased their services to various recipients, for purposes of the exclusive benefit rule of IRC § 401(a)(2), the employees were not employees of the leasing company, primarily because the leasing company exercised no meaningful control over them. The court based its conclusion on the facts including that: (1) the leasing company never exercised its right to reassign workers;  (2) the leasing company had no reason to reassign or fire a worker unless a recipient complained, an unlikely scenario because most workers had some control over the recipient to which they were leased through employees’ equity ownership in the recipient;  (3) the leasing company’s control over the workers’ salaries was illusory, because any change required approval by either the recipient or the worker; and (4) the leasing company did not conduct any screening of the workers except to verify their licenses to practice.
The court also noted that the recipient companies rather than the leasing company, provided the equipment, tools and office space for the workers, furnished the workers with malpractice insurance, and controlled the details of how and when work was to be performed.
Therefore, the court held that the employees were really employees of the recipient companies and not the leasing company, and therefore participation by such employees in the leasing company’s retirement plans would violate the exclusive benefit rule of IRC § 401(a)(2) that a plan of an employer must be for the exclusive benefit of its employees.
If a leasing company exercises meaningful control over the workers, the workers are not significant shareholders of the leasing company, the leasing company has control over salaries and screens the workers as any company hiring an employee will do, workers would probably not be a common-law employee of the client company.
Six Factor Economic Realities Test Used in Second Circuit Co-Employer Case
In a 2003 Second Circuit case, Zheng v. Liberty Apparel Co.[18]—which involved a garment company which hired subcontractors who in turned hired garment workers to stitch and finish pieces of clothing, and whether the company was a “joint employer” with the subcontractors—the court applied a six factor economic realities test to determine if the company was a joint employer of the subcontractors’ workers:
(1) whether the company’s premises and equipment are used for the workers’ work; (2) whether the subcontractors that hired the workers has a business that can or does shift as a unit from one putative joint employer to another; (3) the extent to which the workers perform a discrete line-job that is integral to the company’s process of production; (4) whether responsibility under a contract between the subcontractors and the company could pass from one subcontractor to another without material change; (5) the degree to which the company or its agents supervise the employees’ work; and (6) whether the employee works exclusively or predominantly for the company.[19]
Rev. Proc. 2002-21—Employees of PEO Are Actually Employees of Recipient Company, and Each Employer Must Sign Onto Leasing Company’s 401(k) Plan
Rev. Proc. 2002-21, as amplified by Rev. Proc. 2003-86, provides that professional employer organizations (PEOs) that maintain a defined contribution plan must treat the plan as a multiple-employer plan. Citing the cases of Darden and Professional & Executive Leasing, the IRS acknowledges the complexity involved in the determination of whether a leased employee is the common law employee of the PEO or of the client organization, and provides a framework under which plans sponsored by PEOs will not be treated as violating the exclusive benefit rule solely because they provide benefits to the leased employee. The relief offered is for the PEO either to terminate its plan or to convert its plan into a multiple employer plan IRC § 413(c), and avoid possible violation of the exclusive benefit rule of IRC § 401(a)(2).
This revenue procedure evidences the IRS’ bias towards finding employees of professional employer organizations to be employees solely of the service recipient companies and not of the PEOs. However, if a leasing company maintains primary control over the employee and the Company does not maintain the primary control, and some of the other criteria also point to ownership, the presumption of Rev. Proc. 2002-21 should be negated. Note also that the revenue procedure only deals with retirement plans sponsored by the professional employer organization and not retirement plans of the service recipient company.
PEO Health Plans as MEWAs
If employees of a PEO are characterized as common law employees of the client companies, the PEO health plan would be a multiple employer welfare arrangement (“MEWA”). MEWAs have limited ERISA preemption under ERISA § 514(b)(6). MEWAs are subject to state insurance laws regarding required reserves and contributions. This can create an issue for self-insured plans. With insured plans, however, the insurance company presumably already meets the reserves and contributions requirements.
See, DOL Information Letter (Mar. 1, 2006),[20] that the PEO and its clients would not be considered a single employer even if the PEO had agreements with each of its clients under which the PEO has an option to purchase an 80% interest in each client company, since the options arrangements are really shams. Therefore the MEWA issue was not avoided in that case.
For self-insured MEWAs the state insurance reserves and contributions laws would effectively shut down the MEWA. For insured MEWAs the insurance company already should be satisfying the reserves and contributions requirements, but a DOL Form M-1 filing would be required for both types of MEWAs, whether insured or self-insured. ERISA § 101(g) and DOL Reg. § 2520.101-2 require MEWAs to file annual Form M-1 with the DOL (with $1000 a day penalties under ERISA § 502(c)(5) for failure to file).
This is a very common area of noncompliance, as PEOs may be aware of Rev. Proc. 2002-21 but are often not aware of the MEWA requirements.
Right to Discharge Employee as a Factor in Determining Employee Classification
Note that Treas. Reg. § 1.3121(d)-1(c) regarding Social Security and Medicare withholding provides that: “The right to discharge is also an important factor indicating that the person possessing that right is an employer.”
However the legislative history regarding changes made by the Small Business Job Protection Act of 1996 to IRC § 414(n)(2)(C) (adding primary direction and control language to definition of leased employee) states: “Factors that generally are not relevant in determining whether such direction or control exists include whether the service recipient has the right to hire or fire the individual and whether the individual works for others.”[21]
The above regulation and legislative history can perhaps be reconciled as follows. If the determination is whether the worker is an employee or independent contractor like in the FICA regulations, right to discharge is an important factor indicating that the person possessing that right is the employer. However, in the leased employee situation in determining whether the company is the employer or the leasing organization is employer, whether the service recipient company has the right to hire or fire the individual is not relevant because even a nonemployer client of a PEO would want the right to remove a leased worker if not satisfied with the work.
Case Holding that Leased Employees Were Legitimately Classified as Employees of the Leasing Company
In Castiglione v. U. S. Life Insurance Co.,[22] the court found that a leasing company, rather than the company to which the leasing company leased employees, was the employer for purposes of an ERISA plan. The company to which employees were leased had entered an employee leasing contract with the leasing company, wherein the leasing company agreed to ensure the recipient company’s adherence to federal, state, and local tax laws, payroll, workers’ compensation laws and to provide group health and life insurance. In honoring this agreement the leasing company purchased several insurance policies for employees. The court noted that ERISA § 3(5) merely requires a leasing agency to act “directly as an employer or indirectly in the interests of an employer, in relation to an employee benefit plan.” The court found that the leasing agency was the employee’s direct employer in relation to the employee benefits plan, even though it did not control the employee’s day to day activities. In addition, in any event it would be no less than an indirect employer.
Leasing Organization for Only One Company
A professional employer organization that services numerous companies (e.g., Administaff, ADP, Paychex, Trinet, etc.) is less likely to be attacked as illusory, than an organization set up for solely one employer. It is easier to demonstrate that a large professional employer organization exerts sufficient control independent of the client company with respect to its employees when there are numerous clients and employees are sent on varying assignments for varying periods of time.
5.   If Primarily Under Direction and Control of Company Then Treated As § 414 (n) Leased Employee and Must Be Aggregated for Testing
There are two ways that leasing company employees would be required to be tested together with company employees for nondiscrimination testing. First, if found to be  a common-law employee of the company then the employee  must be included in nondiscrimination  testing (and for participation as well unless specifically excluded from the plan based on their status or based on the classification the employer gave to them at the time). Second, even if not a common-law employee of the company if they are leased employees as defined in IRC § 414(n) as described below, they would also have to be aggregated for testing (but not for participation, assuming the plans exclude leased employees). [23]
Leased Employees Under § 414(n) Must be Aggregated with All Company Employees for Nondiscrimination Testing
Under IRC § 414(n), a leased employee as defined in § 414(n) is treated as an employee of the service recipient.
IRC § 414(n)(3) requires that a leased employee as defined in § 414(n) be treated as an employee of the service recipient for the following requirements: (1) the general nondiscrimination requirements of IRC § 401(a)(4) and the ADP/ACP nondiscrimination requirements of IRC §§ 401(k)(3) & 401(m)(2) (unless the leased employees are specifically excluded by the document from participation); (2) the minimum participation requirements of IRC § 401(a)(26); (3) the minimum coverage requirements of IRC § 410; (4) the top-heavy requirements of IRC § 416; and (5) the maximum benefit and annual addition requirements of IRC § 415.
Leased Employee Under § 414(n) Defined as Service Provider for One Year or More Where Services Are Performed Under Primary Direction or Control of Service Recipient
“Leased employee” is defined in IRC § 414(n)(2) as any person who is not an employee of the service recipient and who provided services to the recipient company if: (1) such services are provided pursuant to an agreement between the service recipient and the leasing organization, (2) such person has performed such services for the service recipient on a substantially full-time basis for a period of at least one year, and (3) such services are performed under the primary direction or control of the service recipient.
Criteria for Determining Whether Services Are Performed Under Primary Direction or Control of Service Recipient—Similar to Common-Law Employee Definition
See legislative history to the Small Business Job Protection Act of 1996 § 1454, which provides: “Whether services are performed by an individual under primary direction or control by the service recipient depends on the facts and circumstances. In general, primary direction and control means that the service recipient exercises the majority of direction and control over the individual. Factors that are relevant in determining whether primary direction or control exists include whether the individual is required to comply with instructions of the service recipient about when, where, and how he or she is to perform the services, whether the services must be performed by a particular person, whether the individual is subject to the supervision of the service recipient, and whether the individual must perform services in the order or sequence set by the service recipient. Factors that generally are not relevant in determining whether such direction or control exists include whether the service recipient has the right to hire or fire the individual and whether the individual works for others.”[24] Note that as defined by the Conference Report, the “primary direction or control” test of IRC § 414(n)(2) is similar to the common-law employee test that service recipient has the right to control and direct the individual as to the details and means by which the work is accomplished. However, it could possibly  not be a common law employee because the recipient company does not have the right to control the details and means by which the work is accomplished, but nevertheless the worker is under the primary direction and control of the recipient company under § 414(n)(2).
6. Consequences of Misclassification of Leased Employees; Self-Audit
As discussed above, the consequences of misclassification of independent contractors would trigger obligations for income tax withholding, and payment of FICA, FUTA, state unemployment and workers compensation. However, in the case of worksite/leased employees, if the entities are treated as co-employers and in all events the government will receive payments from one of the parties, and the company recipient is treated as the sole employer, the government may collect from the employer and the leasing company will have to seek a refund for amounts paid.
If the IRS considers the recipient company to be co-employer with the leasing organization but not sole employer, since the government has already collected income tax withholding, FICA, FUTA, state unemployment and workers compensation from the leasing company, the government will generally not seek a duplicate payment from the recipient company since a co-employer has already paid the amount
The adverse consequences of reclassification of leased employees as employees of the recipient company or as § 414(n) leased employees is that there may be retroactive benefits claims under the company’s benefit plans, although if the plans specifically exclude those misclassified (or determined not to be leased employees as defined in § 414(n)) until reclassified, this won’t be a problem.
If reclassified or if determined to be leased employees as defined in § 414(n), the company would have to retroactively test its qualified plans for nondiscrimination taking into account that the leasing company employees have not been included in the plans—and since they are non-highly compensated employees the company would likely fail the nondiscrimination tests.
An additional, adverse impact could occur if the addition of employees to the company would bring it over the threshold for certain employment laws.[25]
A company that has leased employee arrangements where the company exerts a significant amount of control over the leased employee, such that the company may be the employer or co-employer, should conduct self-audit to determine if the treatment of the employees as employees of the PEO is proper.  The audit should be done with or under the direction of legal counsel in order to retain attorney-client privilege.


[2] 36 BNA Pen. & Ben. Rptr. 2736 (Dec 1, 2009).
[4] See, e.g., Rev. Rul. 66-162, (sales clerks were employees of both the concessionaire who leased space at a department store and the department store);  Chief Counsel Adv. Memo. 200415008 (PEO and clients were co-employers and where PEO went bankrupt, client company could be eligible for employment taxes);  Chief Counsel Adv. Memo. 200017041 (FICA/FUTA wage base applicable to staffing company and clients as co-employers)
[5] See, e.g., Professional & Executive Leasing, Inc. v. Commissioner, 862 F.2d 751 (9th Cir. 1988) (discussed below, and holding that where a leasing company leased employees to various companies, the employees were not employees of the leasing company at all and therefore the leasing company violated the exclusive benefit rule of IRC § 401(a)(2) by including such employees in the leasing company’s plans.)
[6] 503 U.S. 318 (1992).
[7] 503 U.S. at 323–324 (emphasis and format added).
[8] See, however, Second Circuit Zheng decision below applying a six factor “economic realities” test  in a co-employer case.
[9] The same definition is used in Treas. Reg. § 31.3401(c)-1(b), regarding income tax withholding, and Treas. Reg. § 31.3306(i)-1(b), regarding FUTA federal unemployment.
[10] See, e.g., Publication 15-A—Employer’s Supplemental Tax Guide http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p15a.pdf (page 6), and Publication 1779—Independent Contractor or Employee…) http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p1779.pdf 
[11] http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/fss8.pdf   Form SS-8 may be filed by either the business or the worker.
[13] There has been proposed legislation to repeal or amend Section 530.  Recent proposed legislation regarding worker classification include the Taxpayer Responsibility, Accountability and Consistency Act (S. 2882), and The Fair Playing Field Act of 2010 (H.R. 6128), both of which would repeal Section 530. 
[14] See 37 BNA Pen. & Ben. Rptr. 1519 (July 6, 2010).
[15] 120 F.3d 1006 (9th Cir. 1997), cert. denied, 118 S. Ct. 889 (1998).
[16] The Microsoft case was settled for approximately $97 million.
[17] 862 F.2d 751 (9th Cir. 1988).
[18] 355 F.3d 61 (2nd Cir. 2003).
[19] The case was remanded to the district court for further proceedings.
[21] Conference Report to H.R. 3448 (1996).
[22] 262 F. Supp. 2d 1025 (D. Ariz. 2003).
[23] IRC § 414(m) affiliated service rules could be applicable if the owners of the service organization are also employees or shareholders of the recipient company.
[24] Conference Report, 1982-2 C.B. 522, 679.
[25] For example, 15 employees are required for application of  the Americans With Disabilities Act and  Title VII, 20 employees for the Age Discrimination in Employment Act and COBRA, 50 employees for the Family and Medical Leave Act, 100 employees for WARN Act, etc.
Categories
Blog

SUMMARY OF FOUR DIFFERENT RULES (OR PROPOSED RULES) RELATING TO 401(K) FEE DISCLOSURE OR INVESTMENT ADVICE GUIDANCE

Charles C. Shulman, Esq., LLC
Employee Benefits, Employment & Executive Compensation Law
www.ebeclaw.com  – www.EmployeeBenefitsLaw.info

<>

<>

632 Norfolk St., Teaneck, NJ 07666

NJ Tel – 201-357-0577
(rings in office & on cell)
Fax – 201-836-4847
NY Office:
345

Seventh Ave.

, 21 Fl., New York, NY

NY Tel – 212-380-3834
E-mail – cshulman@ebeclaw.com
Admitted in NY & NJ

EBEC (Employee Benefits / Executive Compensation) Law Update

August 17, 2010
Updated December 19, 2010

SUMMARY OF FOUR DIFFERENT RULES (OR PROPOSED RULES) RELATING
TO 401(K) FEE DISCLOSURE OR INVESTMENT ADVICE GUIDANCE
            Recent guidance – some proposed and some final – relate to 401(k) plan fee disclosure and investment advice, as described further below:
  • Service provider disclosure on Form 5500 Schedule C is now required for both direct and indirect compensation.  This became effective with the 5500s for the 2009 plan years.
  • Fee disclosure by service providers to responsible plan fiduciaries to show reasonableness of contract (required by service-provider exemption of ERISA § 408(b)(2)) as specified in interim final DOL regulations published in July of this year will become effective July 16, 2011.
  • Fee disclosure by fiduciaries to participants for participant-directed 401(k) plans regarding investment options with a comparative chart of investment options and with the administrative expenses of each option is required under DOL regulations proposed in July 2008 and finalized in Oct. 2010.
  • Regulations regarding investment advice arrangements that are permitted by the Pension Protection Act where there is level-fee or computer model arrangements have been reproposed in March 2010.  They were originally finalized in January 2009 but were later withdrawn.  The reproposed regulations are similar to the original regulations but with certain changes as described below.

      1.  Schedule C Service Provider Reporting – Effective for 2009 Plan Years  
            Final guidance for revised Form 5500 Schedule C disclosure provides for expanded requirements for service providers reporting of direct and indirect compensation, and requires fiduciaries to review and approve expenses, effective for 5500s relating to plan years beginning in 2009. 
  • For Schedule C purposes, reportable compensation includes cash and any other items of value (e.g., gifts or awards) received from the plan (including fees charged as a percentage of assets and deducted from investment returns) in connection with services rendered to the plan.  
  • Indirect compensation is compensation received from sources other than the plan or plan sponsor, in connection with services rendered to the plan, and would include, for example, fees and expense reimbursement payments received from a mutual fund, account maintenance fees, 12b–1 distribution fees, etc.[1]

2.  Fee Disclosure for Service Providers – Interim Final Regulations Effective July 16, 2011
ERISA § 406 generally prohibits transactions between an ERISA plan and a party in interest.  A service provider to a plan would be a party in interest, making the arrangement a prohibited transaction.  However, under the service-provider exception, ERISA § 408(b)(2) exempts service contracts or arrangements between a plan and a party in interest if (i) the contract or arrangement is reasonable, (ii) the services are necessary for the establishment or operation of the plan, and (iii) no more than reasonable compensation is paid for the services.[2]
DOL regulations § 2550.408b-2, proposed in December 2007[3] and substantially revised as interim regulations in July 2010[4]  amends DOL Reg. § 2550.408b–2 to clarify the meaning of a ‘‘reasonable’’ contract or arrangement.
Under the interim DOL regulations, to be a reasonable contract, a “covered service provider” (as defined below) must disclose in writing to the “responsible plan fiduciary” (the fiduciary with authority to cause the plan to enter into or renew the contract) certain information. 
·         This disclosure is in order for the fiduciary to be able to determine that the services are reasonable.
A “covered service provider” is a service provider that enters into a contract or arrangement with a covered plan (which is defined as an ERISA pension plan) and reasonably expects $1,000 or more in direct or indirect compensation to be received in connection with providing certain enumerated services, which are services provided as a fiduciary to an investment contract, product or other entity holding plan assets, services provided as an investment advisor  to the plan, certain recordkeeping and brokerage services and other services for which service provider, affiliate or subcontractor expect to receive indirect compensation. DOL Reg. § 2550.408b-2(c)(1)(iii).
The disclosure must describe:
·         services to be provided (but not including non-fiduciary services to an investment contract or plan investment);
·         if applicable, status as a fiduciary or investment advisor;
·         any direct or indirect compensation the service provider, affiliate, or subcontractor expects to receive, or in certain cases any compensation that will be paid between the service provider, affiliate and a subcontractor in connection with the services (e.g., bundled services such as commissions, 12b-1 fees, soft dollar fees, etc.);
·         compensation expected in connection with termination of the contract;
·         with regard to recordkeeping services a description of direct and indirect compensation that is expected to be received;
·         whether the plan will be billed or the compensation will be deducted directly from the plan’s individual accounts;
·         for fiduciary service providers with respect to plan assets, any compensation that will be charged directly against the amount invested in connection with the acquisition, sale, or withdrawal of the investment (e.g., sales charges, loads, redemption fees, surrender charges, etc.) and operating expenses; and
·         for certain recordkeeping and brokerage services with respect to each designated investment alternative, current accurate disclosure materials of the issuer of the designated investment alternative that includes the information in the previous bullet.[5] 
The service provider must disclose any additional information relating to compensation to the responsible plan fiduciary within the following time periods: (i) reasonably in advance of the date of contract or renewed, (ii) within 30 days of when the investment holds plan assets, and (iii) as soon as an investment alternative is designated.[6]  Changes in the disclosed information must be communicated no later than 60 days from the date of change.[7]  
Upon request, the service provider must furnish other information relating to the compensation received in connection with the contract.[8]  Good faith errors or omission in disclosing the information required will not cause there to be a failure, as long as the service provider discloses the correct information as soon as practicable and no later than 30 days after the service provider knows of such error or omission.[9]

There is an exemption in the form of a prohibited transaction class exemption, and also incorporated into the interim regulations, for the responsible plan fiduciary from the prohibited transaction restrictions for a party in interest providing goods and services to or receiving assets from the plan, for any failure by a covered service provider to disclose the information required above, provided that the following conditions are met: (i) the plan fiduciary did not know that the service provider failed or would fail to make required disclosures and reasonably believed that the covered service provider disclosed the information required above, (ii) the plan fiduciary requests the additional information in writing and notifies  the DOL, and (iii) the service provider terminates the arrangement or complies with the request within 90 days.  DOL Reg. § 2550.408b-2(c)(1)(ix).  The above administrative class exemption was proposed in December 2007[10] and finalized in July 2010.[11]

                The interim regulations also require that for the contract to be reasonable, it must permit termination of the contract without penalty other than for reasonable start-up costs and expenses.[12]  

The interim regulations will not be effective until July 16, 2011. The rules will then apply to all contracts or arrangements, regardless of whether entered into before or after the effective date.

      3.  Fee Disclosure for Participants – Final Regulations (Generally Effective 1/1/2012)
            Generally.  The Department of Labor has issued regulations – proposed in 2008[13] and finalized in 2010[14] – requiring fiduciaries of individual account plans to provide specific disclosures to participants concerning plan investment options including fee and expense information.  The concern is that participants in individual account plans be given sufficient information on investment choices including fees and expenses.[15]
The regulations provide that when a plan allocates investment responsibilities to participants under a participant directed individual account plan, the plan administrator must make sure that participants are made aware of their rights and responsibilities with respect to the investment of assets, and that sufficient information is provided regarding the plan and the plan’s investment options including fee and expense information to make informed decisions how to invest their accounts.[16]
The plan administrator must provide participants certain plan-related information and certain investment-related information, as described below.[17]  
Plan-Related Information.   The plan-related information that must be disclosed includes:
·         general plan information about structure and mechanics of plan, such as how to give investment instructions, list of plan’s current investment options, description of any “brokerage windows” or similar arrangement that enables the selection of investments beyond those designated by the plan, etc;[18] 
·         administrative expenses information about fees and expenses for general plan administrative services that may be charged to individual accounts, such as fees and expenses for legal, accounting, and recordkeeping services;[19]  and
·         individual expense information including fees and expenses that may be charged to individual account of participant, such as fees for plan loans and for processing QDROs.[20]
This information must be given to participants on or before the date they can direct their investments, and then annually thereafter.[21] 
Statements must be furnished to participants at least quarterly showing the dollar amount of the plan-related administrative and individual fees and expenses actually charged to the individual accounts, as well as a description of the services.  These disclosures may be included in quarterly benefit statements required under ERISA § 105.[22] 
Investment-Related Information.  In addition to plan-related information, investment-related information must also be disclosed under the regulations.[23]   This includes:
·         performance data, with historical investment performance; one, five and ten-year returns must be provided for investment options that do not have fixed rates of return (such as mutual funds), and for investment options that have a fixed rate of return the annual rate of return must be provided;[24]
·         benchmark information for investment options that do not have a fixed rate of return, with the returns of an appropriate broad-based securities market index over one-, five-, and ten-year periods (investment options with fixed rates of return are not subject to this requirement);[25]
·         fee and expense information, which for investment options that do not a have a fixed rate of return requires total annual operating expenses expressed as both a percentage of assets and as a dollar amount and any shareholder-type fees or restrictions on the participant’s ability to purchase or withdraw from the investment; for investment options that have a fixed rate of return, any shareholder-type fees or restrictions on the participant’s ability to purchase or withdraw from the investment is required;[26]
·         Internet website address must be included for investment-related information, which will provide participants access to specific additional information about the investment options if more current information is desired;[27] and
·         a glossary of investment-related terms to understand the plan’s investment options, or an Internet website address that provides access to such a glossary.[28]
Comparative Format Requirement.  Investment-related information must be furnished on or before the date participants can first direct their investments, and annually thereafter; this information must be furnished in a chart format to facilitate comparison of investment options. The regulations include an appendix with a model comparative chart.[29]
Effective Dates.  The final regulations become effective on December 20, 2010.  They become applicable to covered individual account plans for plan years beginning on or after November 1, 2011.[30]

      4.  Eligible Investment Advice Arrangements by Fiduciary Advisors Under Pension Protection Act  –Regulations Withdrawn and then Reproposed
Under ERISA § 408, as amended by the Pension Protection Act of 2006, a prohibited transaction statutory exemption is added for the provision of investment advice by a “fiduciary advisor” to participants of participant-directed plans through an “eligible investment advice arrangement.”  ERISA §§ 408(b)(14) & 408(g). 
In January 2009 the Department of Labor finalized regulations implementing the provisions of the statutory exemption for eligible investment advice arrangements for level-fee or computer model arrangements (as described below).[31]  The DOL also provided an administrative class exemption in DOL Reg. § 2550.408g-1(d), pursuant to which the fee-leveling or computer model requirements would be liberalized.  The effective date was to have been March 23, 2009.   The effective date was delayed several times.[32]  The DOL withdrew these regulations entirely effective January 19, 2010 (before the extended effective date of the regulations).[33]
The regulations were reproposed in March of 2010.[34]  Reproposed DOL Reg. § 2550.408g–1 follows the requirements of ERISA § 408(g) that must be satisfied in order for the investment advice-related arrangements to be exempt from the prohibited transaction restrictions of § 406.  
“Eligible investment advice arrangements” must either:  (i) be based on generally accepted investment theories, taking into account fees and expenses and the participants’ age, other assets, risk tolerance and preferences, and must also provide that fees received by fiduciary advisors providing investment advice do not vary on the basis of the investments chosen (level fee arrangements);[35] or (ii) use a computer model that provides generally accepted investment theories, use relevant information about participants, take into account fees and expenses, use appropriate objective criteria, not favor investment options of the advisor and take into account all of the investment options of the plan, and in addition, the computer model must be certified by an eligible investment expert.[36] 
A plan fiduciary must expressly authorize the investment advice program, and an annual audit of the arrangement must be made.[37]  
The fiduciary advisor must disclose to participants prior to the initial investment advice the following: (i) the role of any party that has a material affiliation, (ii) past performance of the investment options, (iii) fees or compensation that the advisor or affiliate receives for the advice or for a transaction or rollover involving the investment, (iv) any material affiliation the fiduciary or affiliate has in the funds, and (v) certain other matters.[38]  The Appendix to Prop. DOL Reg. § 2550.408g-1 contains a model disclosure form that may be used to satisfy this disclosure requirement. 
A “fiduciary advisor” is a registered investment advisor, bank, insurance company, registered broker dealer or an affiliate or employee of any of the above.[39]   
The proposed regulations address the requirements for electing to be treated as the only fiduciary and fiduciary adviser by reason of developing or marketing a computer model or an investment advice program used in an eligible investment advice arrangement. [40] 
A prohibited transaction class exemption in the original 2009 regulations would have permitted follow-up individual advice subsequent to the computer model, and would have also permitted varying fees as long as the individual employee providing the advice met the level fee requirements.  However, in response to comments questioning the potential for self-dealing, the class exemption has been eliminated in the reproposed regulations.
The regulations will most likely be effective 60 days after finalization and publication of the final regulations in the Federal Register.[41] 

            IRS Circular 230 Disclosure: To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the IRS, we inform you that any U.S. federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction or matter that is contained in this document.


[1]     72 Fed. Reg. 64710 (Nov.16, 2007), amending DOL Reg. §§ 2520.103-1 & 2520.104-46. 
      Note that the various references to regulations or proposed regulations in the footnotes below are hyperlinked to the original texts in the Federal Register.
[2]     A related rule also added by the Pension Protection Act of 2006 adds ERISA § 408(b)(17) provides that if a person  is a party-in-interest solely by reason of providing services to the plan, and is not an investment advisor to the plan, then transactions under ERISA § 406(a)(i)(A), (B) or (D) (sale, exchange, lease or loan) will not be prohibited, so long as the plan pays no more than, and receives no less than adequate consideration.  There are currently no regulations regarding § 408(b)(17).
[3]     72 Fed. Reg. 70988 (Dec 13, 2007).  The proposed regulations had been put on hold in connection with President Obama’s January 2009 sixty day regulatory moratorium for proposed regulations and regulations not yet effective. 74 Fed. Reg. 4435 (Jan. 26, 2009).    
[4]     75 Fed. Reg. 41600 (July 16, 2010).
[5]     DOL Reg. § 2550.408b-2(c)(1)(iv).
[6]     DOL Reg. § 2550.408b-2(c)(1)(v). 
[7]     Id.
[8]     DOL Reg. § 2550.408b-2(c)(1)(vi).
[9]     DOL Reg. § 2550.408b-2(c)(1)(vii).
[10]    72 Fed. Reg. 70893 (Dec. 13, 2007).
[11]    75 Fed. Reg. 41600 (July 16, 2010). 
[12]    DOL Reg. § 2550.408b-2(c)(3).
[13]    DOL Reg. §§ 2550.404a-5 and 2550.404c-1, 73 Fed. Reg. 43014 (July 23, 2008). 
[14]    DOL Reg. §§ 2550.404a-5 and 2550.404c-1, 75 Fed. Reg. 64910 (Oct. 20, 2010). 
[15]    Preamble to regulations, 75 Fed. Reg. at 64910.
[16]    DOL Reg. § 2550.404a-5(a).
[17]    Id.
[18]    DOL Reg. § 2550.404a-5(c)(1).
[19]    DOL Reg. § 2550.404a-5(c)(2).
[20]    DOL Reg. § 2550.404a-5(c)(3).
[21]    DOL Reg. § 2550.404a-5(c)(1)(i), (c)(2)(i) & (c)(3)(i).
[22]    DOL Reg. § 2550.404a-5(c)(2)(ii) & -5(c)(3)(ii).
[23]    DOL Reg. § 2550.404a-5(d).
[24]    DOL Reg. § 2550.404a-5(d)(1)(ii).
[25]    DOL Reg. § 2550.404a-5(d)(1)(iii).
[26]    DOL Reg. § 2550.404a-5(d)(1)(iv).
[27]    DOL Reg. § 2550.404a-5(d)(1)(v).
[28]    DOL Reg. § 2550.404a-5(d)(1)(vi).
[29]    DOL Reg. § 2550.404a-5(d)(2).
[30]    DOL Reg. § 2550.404a-5(j).
[31]    74 Fed. Reg. 3822 (Jan. 21, 2009) (DOL Reg. § 2550.408g-1 & -2), originally proposed in 73 Fed. Reg. 49896 (Aug 22, 2008).
[32]    It was delayed 60 days to May 22, 2009, 74 Fed. Reg. 11847 (March 20, 2009), per President Obama’s regulatory moratorium (74 Fed. Reg. 4435 (Jan. 26, 2009)), it was deferred another 180 days to November 18, 2009, 74 Fed. Reg. 23951 (May 20, 2009), and it was deferred another 180 days until May 17, 2010, 74 Fed. Reg. 59092 (Nov. 17, 2009).
[33]    74 Fed. Reg. 60156 (Nov. 20, 2009).
[34]    75 Fed. Reg. 9360 (March 2, 2010).
[35]    Prop. DOL Reg. § 2550.408g-1(b)(3). See similarly, ERISA § 408(g)(2). 
      The reproposed regulations provide that, as stated in DOL Field Assistance Bulletin 2007-01 (Feb. 2, 2007),  the receipt by a fiduciary adviser of any payment from any party or used for the benefit of such fiduciary adviser that is based on investments selected by participants would be inconsistent with the fee-leveling requirement of the exemption.

[36]    Prop. DOL Reg. § 2550.408g-1(b)(4). See similarly, ERISA § 408(g)(3).
      The reproposed regulation also provide, in connection with investment advice arrangements that use computer models, that a computer model shall be designed and operated to avoid investment recommendations that inappropriately distinguish among investment options within a single asset class on the basis of a factor that cannot confidently be expected to persist in the future.
[37]    Prop. DOL Reg. § 2550.408g-1(b)(5) & (6).  See similarly, ERISA § 408(g)(4) & (5).
[38]    Prop. DOL Reg. § 2550.408g-1(b)(7).  See similarly, ERISA § 408(g)(6).
[39]    Prop. DOL Reg. § 2550.408g-1(c)(2).  See similarly, ERISA § 408(g)(11).
[40]    Prop. DOL Reg. § 2550.408g–2.
[41]    Pending final regulations the statutory exemption for investment advice provided by the PPA is still in effect (for advice after 2006), and a good faith compliance should suffice until regulations are refinalized.     The withdrawal of the regulations and exemption does not negate the statutory exemption in ERISA §§ 408(b)(14) & 408(g) provided for by the PPA for eligible investment advice arrangements.  Note that the guidance in DOL Field Assistance Bulletin 2007-01 can also be be relied upon pending final regulations.
Categories
Blog

EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION PROVISIONS OF DODD-FRANK WALL STREET REFORM AND CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT OF 2010

 

Charles C. Shulman, Esq., LLC
Employee Benefits, Employment & Executive Compensation Law
www.EBEClaw.com

<><>

632 Norfolk St., Teaneck, NJ 07666
NJ Tel – 201-357-0577
(rings in office & on cell)
Fax – 201-836-4847
NY Office:
345 Seventh Ave., 21 Fl., New York, NY 10001
NY Tel – 212-380-3834
E-mail – cshulman@ebeclaw.com
Admitted in NY & NJ

EBEC (Employee Benefits / Executive Compensation) Law Update
[December 15, 2010]
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION PROVISIONS OF DODD-FRANK
WALL STREET REFORM AND CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT OF 2010
The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010, P.L. 111-203, H.R. 4173, signed July 21, 2010 (“Dodd-Frank Act” or “Act”), contains say-on-pay and other shareholder-accountability executive compensation proxy rules.
1.   Say-on-Pay.  Section 951 of Dodd-Frank Act adds new § 14A(a) (15 USC §78n-1(b)) to the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 that a non-binding shareholder vote on executive compensation must be held every 1,2 or 3 years (with frequency elected in a separate shareholder vote at least once every 6 years).
The “say-on-pay” vote is on compensation of named executive officers as disclosed in the executive compensation disclosure of the proxy.
The say on pay vote is non-binding – it is advisory only – and it does not create any additional fiduciary duties. Previously, optional say on pay votes required a preliminary proxy. A preliminary proxy will not be required for mandatory say on pay vote, according to proposed rules as discussed below.
2.   Say-On-Golden Parachutes.  Section 951 of the Dodd-Frank Act adds § 14A(b) to the Securities Exchange Act that a proxy or consent solicitation with a shareholder vote to approve a transaction, requires disclosure and a separate non-binding vote for any agreements with named executive officers relating to compensation (present, deferred or contingent) that is based on or relates to an acquisition, merger, consolidation, sale or other disposition of substantially of all the assets (“golden parachutes”) and the total of such compensation that may be paid out.
3.   Effective Date.  The various shareholder vote requirements such as say on pay, frequency of vote and say on golden parachute become effective on the first shareholder meeting occurring on or after January 21, 2011 (6 months after enactment of Dodd-Frank Act). No rulemaking is required to trigger the effective date.
4.   Proposed Regulations on Say-on-Pay.  The SEC released proposed rules and amendments to rules relating to the above say-on-pay and say-on-golden parachute requirements of the Dodd-Frank Act. 17 CFR Parts 229, 240 and 249, 75 Fed. Reg. 66590 (Oct. 28, 2010). (All references below to regulations are to these proposed regulations and proposed amendments to regulations.)
a.  Annual Proxies. Say-on-Pay is only required in proxies for election of directors.
b.  Say on all NEO 402 Pay.  Vote of say-on-pay is for all Item 402 compensation for named executive officers (including CD&A, tables are other narrative disclosure under Item 402 Rule 14(a)-21(a), 17 CFR § 240-14a-21(a). This vote is not required for director compensation.
c.  Vote.  The vote is on approval of compensation of executives as disclosed under Item 402 of Reg. S-K.
d.   Vote on Frequency of Say-on-Pay Vote. Choice of voting frequency is one year, two years or three years (and shareholder can also abstain). Rule 14a-21(b).
e.   No Preliminary Proxy. No preliminary proxy is required for shareholder say-on-pay vote or frequency vote. Rule 14a-6(a).
f.  Compensation Discussion & Analysis. Item 402(b) is changed so that disclosure is required in CD&A as to whether and how the company’s compensation policy takes into account the prior say on pay vote.
5.            Proposed Regulations on Say on Golden Parachute.  These proposed rules also govern say on golden parachutes.
a.       Separate Vote in Transaction Proxy. Proposed rules provide that in a proxy or consent solicitation to approve an acquisition, merger, consolidation or sale of substantially all of assets, a separate shareholder vote is required to approve any type of compensation (whether present, deferred or contingent) that is based on or relates to the transaction. 17 CFR § 240.14a-21(c) & § 229.402(t)(1)
b.       Separate Golden Parachute Vote Not Required if Already Approved in Annual Proxy. The vote on golden parachutes is not required if such golden parachutes were already approved in the regular annual (or bi or tri-annual) proxy vote assuming the applicable 402(t) golden parachute chart has been included in  the annual proxy.  17 CFR § 240.14a-21.
c.       Golden Parachute Table. Golden parachute compensation disclosure, where required, shall include under proposed Item 402(t) a golden parachute compensation table with the named executive officers and the dollar value of cash severance, accelerated stock options, and other  stocks awards, payments in cancellation of such awards, pension and deferred compensation benefit enhancements, prerequisites, tax reimbursements (such as 280G gross-ups) and other personal benefits, and any other compensation payable on account of the transaction. 17 CFR § 229.402(t).
d.       Footnotes to Golden Parachute Table.  Footnote should disclose each separate form of compensation and shall indicate if it is a single trigger or a double trigger.  Even change in control compensation from broad-based plans must be disclosed to the extent it affects the named executive officers.
e.       Narrative Golden Parachute Disclosure. Item 402(t)(3) requires narrative description of material factors applicable to the change in control payments in the chart, including conditions of payment, form of payment, noncompetes and confidentiality agreements.
6.   Recovery of Erroneously Awarded Compensation – Expanded Clawbacks.  Section 954 of the Dodd-Frank Act adds securities Exchange Act § 10D, which instructs the SEC to direct the listing exchanges to require of the listed companies:
a. Disclosure of the company’s policy regarding incentive compensation based on reported financial information; and
b. Recoupment (clawback) from any current or former executive officer of any incentive compensation paid during the past three years based on erroneous data if the company is required to restate the financials; the recoupment is for the excess of the amount of incentive compensation paid based on the erroneous financial information over what would have been payable under the corrected financial information.
Note that the Dodd-Frank Act clawback is broader than the Sarbanes-Oxley Act clawback in that under Dodd-Frank it applies to erroneous information whether or not there was misconduct, it goes back three years instead of 12 months and it applies to all executive officers not just named executive officers.
7.        Compensation Committees and Compensation Consultant are Advisor Independence.
a.       Compensation Committee Independence. Section 952 of Dodd-Frank Act adds §10C(a) of the Securities Exchange Act instructing stock exchanges to require that listed companies have compensation committee members who are Board members and are also “independent”. The respective stock exchanges will define independent considering compensation paid to the committee members (e.g. consulting or advisory fees) and whether the committee member is affiliated with the company.
A compensation consultant or other advisor may be selected only after the compensation committee has taken into account relevant factors determining independence including: (i) provision of other services to the company by the entity that employs the consultant or advisor; (ii) fees received from the company as a percentage of the total revenue of the entity that employs the consultant or advisor; (iii) policies of the entity employing the consultant or advisor; (iv) any business or personal relationship between the compensation committee and the consultant or advisor; and (v) any stock of the company owned by the compensation consultant or advisor.
b. Authority to Retain Compensation Consultants and Advisors.  Section 952 also adds Securities Exchange Act §§ 10C(c) and (d) that a compensation committee may in its sole discretion retain a compensation consultant legal counsel or other advisors. The compensation committee will be directly responsible for appointment, compensation and    oversight of the work of the consultant or advisor. (The annual proxy must disclose    whether the compensation committee has engaged a compensation consultant and whether there are any conflicts of interest.)
c. Funding Section 10C(e) provides that the company shall provide appropriate funding for reasonable compensation of the committee’s compensation consultant and advisors.
d.  Requirement of Listing Companies and Effective Date  The Dodd-Frank Act provides that the SEC must adopt rules by 360 days after enactment (July 16, 2011) providing that securities exchanges shall prohibit security listing by companies not in compliance with these compensation consultant & advisor rules. § 10C(f).
8. Hedging Disclosure. The proxy must contain a policy regarding permissibility of employees or directors purchasing derivatives to hedge against equity grants. Section 955 of Dodd-Frank Act adding § 14(j) of  the Securities Exchange Act.
9. Joint or Separate CEO & Chairman. Under § 972 of the Dodd-Frank Act  rules are to be issued within 180 days of enactment (Jan. 17, 2011) requiring listed company proxies to disclose why CEO and Chairman are the same person or two separate people.

IRS Circular 230 Disclosure: To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the IRS, we inform you that any U.S. federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction or matter that is contained in this document.
Categories
Blog

NOTICE 2010-80: RELIEF FOR PAYMENTS CONDITIONED ON EXECUTING RELEASES AND FOR § 409A CORRECTION PROGRAMS


Charles C. Shulman, Esq.
Employee Benefits, Employment & Executive Compensation Law
www.EBEClaw.com

<>

<>

632 Norfolk St., Teaneck, NJ 07666
NJ Tel – 201-357-0577
(rings in office & on cell)
Fax – 201-836-4847
NY Office:
345 Seventh Ave., 21 Fl., New York, NY 10001
NY Tel – 212-380-3834
E-mail – cshulman@ebeclaw.com
Admitted in NY & NJ


EBEC (Employee Benefits / Executive Compensation) Law Update
December 6, 2010
NOTICE 2010-80:
RELIEF FOR PAYMENTS CONDITIONED ON EXECUTING
RELEASES AND FOR § 409A CORRECTION PROGRAMS
Notice 2010-80 – Relief With Respect to Correction Methods and Payment Conditioned on Executing Release. Notice 2010-80, issued on Nov. 30, 2010, provides certain relief with respect to the IRC § 409A correction methods described below, as well as with respect to payments conditioned on employment-related action of the employee such as executing a release, as summarized below.
v  IRS Notice 2008-113 described certain self-correction methods for § 409A operational failures, provided the corrections are made in the year of failure or in certain cases in the first or second year following the year of failure.  (The notice also provided certain transitional relief for operational failures occurring before 2008.)   See Feb. 28, 2009 client memo.
v  IRS Notice 2010-6 allowed taxpayers to voluntarily correct many documentary failures under IRC § 409A, including (i) impermissible definitions of payment events, (ii) impermissible payment periods, payment events or payment schedules, (iii) lack of six-month delay, (iv) impermissible initial deferrals, etc.  This notice also provides certain transition rules for corrections on or prior to Dec. 31 2010 or for certain corrections on or prior to Dec. 31, 2011.  
v  Notice 2010-6 also provides relief for payments conditioned on employment-related action of the employee such as executing a release, non-solicitation agreement or non-compete agreement, that correction can be made before the permissible payment event occurs by removing the ability of the employee to delay or accelerate the timing of the payment as a result of his or her actions, and fixing the payment date at 60 (or 90) days after the payment event (with certain other conditions, as outlined below).   See March 7, 2010 client memo for more information.
Severance Conditioned on Executing Release – Expanded Relief.  When payment of severance is conditioned on the employee’s signing a release of claims (including age discrimination waivers), and the employee can sign the release at any time, this could cause the severance to fail to be a short-term deferral or to have or not have a fixed payment date as required by IRC § 409A. 
One solution that practitioners have used is to provide a fixed deadline in which time to execute the release, e.g., the release must be executed and not revoked by the 60th (or 90th) day following termination, and the terms of the release would be agreed upon in advance.  This way, the ADEA 21-day period to consider the release, or the 45-day period in connection with an exit incentive program or other employment termination program, and the 7 days to revoke can be satisfied before the expiration of that period, and the payment is to be made after executing the release at any time within a 60 (or 90) day period after termination.   In addition, in order to avoid an employee being able to control the year of payment, a provision would also need to be added that if the 60 (or 90) day period begins in one taxable year and ends in the next taxable year the payment will automatically be pushed to the next taxable year.
The IRS had indicated informally and in Notice 2010-6, however, that such a solution may not work, because there would be an impermissible toggle by being able to have a different pay option depending on whether the employee executes the release prior to or after November 1.  The solution the IRS suggested is to require is that regardless of whether the release is executed right away, the severance payment will only be made 60 (or 90) days after termination, provided an irrevocable release is in place by then.  This solution is supported by Notice 2010-6 § VI.B, which provides a documentary correction that if payment is conditioned on the employee executing a release, correction can be made before the permissible payment event occurs by removing the ability of the employee to delay or accelerate the timing of the payment as a result of his or her actions, and fixing the payment date at 60 (or 90) days after the payment event.
v  Note that much of the above requirements only apply if the severance arrangement is subject to § 409A, but if the severance can be paid within the short term deferral period (e.g., it has a safe harbor § 409A good reason definition) or within the two years two times pay exception for involuntary terminations, this would avoid application of § 409A and therefore it would not be subject to the toggle rule relating to § 409A payment events or the straddling of two years.  The release would have a fixed deadline that must be executed and become irrevocable within e.g., 60 (or 90) days, and the severance would have to be paid in all events no later than 2-½ months (to ensure that it is a short-term deferral), or within two years if relying on that exception.
The IRS has retreated somewhat from its position requiring a fixed date, and has determined that the first solution – to set a 60 day (or 90 day) deadline for executing the release and receiving payment and to push the payment date to the next year if this period begins in one calendar year and ends in the next year – would also work.  This position is set forth in Notice 2010-80 that payment of severance can be set as payable within a 60 (or 90) day period following the termination (the permissible payment event), assuming the release and non-revocation has occurred, and provided that if such 60 (or 90) day period begins in the employee’s first taxable year and extends into the employee’s second taxable year, the payment must be made in the second taxable year (or alternatively the payment can be set for the last day of the period as per the method described above).[1]
Transition Relief for Severance with Release through Dec. 31, 2012.  Notice 2010-80 also modifies Notice 2010-6 by providing additional transition relief through December 31, 2012 for plans that contain failures involving payments dependent upon the employee executing a release (and the plan is eligible for correction by December 31, 2010 ), provided that any payments made after March 31, 2011 that could be paid during a period that begins in one taxable year and ends in the subsequent taxable year are made during the subsequent taxable year and provided further that to the extent any amounts remain deferred under the plan, the plan is amended to be compliant by no later than December 31, 2012.[2]
Certain Linked Plans and Stock Rights are Included in Documentary Corrections.  Notice 2010-80 amends Notice 2010-6 to provide that the documentary corrections can be utilized: (i) by linked plans (nonqualified plans linked with qualified plans) with document failures if the linkage does not affect the time and form of payment of amounts under the plans; and (ii) by stock rights (stock options and stock appreciation rights) that were intended at the time of grant (or upon a modification pursuant to applicable transition relief) to be subject to and compliant with § 409A but that have a plan document failure.[3]
Relief Regarding Information and Reporting Requirements for Operational Corrections.  Notice 2008-113 provides information and reporting requirements by the employee and employer to make the operational corrections.  For example, with respect to same year corrections, Notice 2008-113 provides that the employer must attach to its federal income tax return for its taxable year in which the failure occurred a statement entitled “Section 409A Relief under Section IV of Notice 2008-113” with specific information about the correction, and the employer must provide to each affected employee a similar statement by the W-2 due date.[4]  Notice 2010-80 amends this provision so that notice to the employee is not required for corrections in the same year of error.[5]
Relief Regarding Information and Reporting Requirements for Documentary Corrections.  An employer with respect to any of the corrections in the notice must attach to its corporate tax returns and to the W-2’s and 1099’s for the year of failure an exhibit entitled “409A Document Correction Under § ___ of  Notice 2010-6,” which must include certain information about the correction.[6]  The affected employees must also be provided with a statement that the employee is entitled to the relief provided in the applicable provision in Notice 2010-6 with respect to a failure to comply with § 409A, and containing the above information about the correction, and that the employee must attach a copy of the statement to his or her income tax return for the taxable year in which the failure was corrected.[7]  Notice 2010-80 modifies Notice 2010-6 to provide that this statement is not required to be furnished by the employer to the employees and is not required to be attached by the employees to their tax returns with respect to transition relief corrections that may be made prior to Dec. 31, 2010, 2011 or 2012, as applicable,[8] although the employer is still required to attach the statement to its return.[9]
Prompt Attention.  If you are unsure if your documents or procedures need corrections, prompt attention is advisable, as certain of the transition rules for corrections end on December 31, 2010. 

IRS Circular 230 Disclosure: To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the IRS, we inform you that any U.S. federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction or matter that is contained in this document.


[1]       Notice 2010-80 § III.B modifying § VI.B.2 of Notice 2010-6.
[2]       Notice 2010-80 § III.C adding § VI.B.3 to Notice 2010-6.
[3]       Notice 2010-80 § III.A.
[4]       Notice 2008-113 § IX.
[5]       Notice 2010-80 § III.H amending Notice 2008-113 § IX.
[6]       Notice 2010-6 § XII.A.  The attachment describing the documentary correction should set forth the name and tax identification number for each service provider affected by the failure, identification of the plan with the failure, a statement that the document failure is eligible for correction (and identifying the specific section of the notice) and stating the amount involved in the documentary error. Notice 2010-6 § XII.B.
[7]       Notice 2010-6 § XII.C.  The employee must attach to his or her tax return a copy of the above statement regarding the failure. § XIII.D.
[8]       The transition relief corrections are in Notice 2010-6 § XI and in Notice 2010-6 § VI.B.3 (as added by Notice 2010-80).
[9]       Sections III.E, F & G of Notice 2010-80 amending § XII of Notice 2010-6. 
Categories
Blog

Enhanced Executive Compensation Disclosure: A Summary of SEC’s 2009 Rules

 BNA PBR 8-4-09 Article Revised
to Reflect 12-23-09 Final Rules – 1/4/2010
Enhanced Executive Compensation Disclosure:
A Summary of SEC’s 2009 Rules
By Charles C. Shulman
Charles C. Shulman practices employee benefits and executive compensation law in New York and New Jersey. He can be reached at cshulman@EBEClaw.com
The Securities and Exchange Commission finalized amendments to its executive compensation and corporate governance disclosure rules that apply to proxy and information statements. This memo discusses amendments relating to disclosure of a company’s compensation policies, director and nominee qualifications, use of consultants, and method of reporting the value of stock awards in the Summary Compensation Table.
On December 23, 2009 the Securities and Exchange Commission published final rules, Proxy Disclosure and Solicitation Enhancements – Release No. 33-9052, 74 Fed. Reg. 68334 (Dec. 23, 2009).  The rules were first proposed July 17, 2009. 74 Fed. Reg. 35,076 (July 17, 2009). The rules as finalized (i) amend the proxy disclosure (S-K) rules at 17 C.F.R. § 229 and other related rules to provide enhanced proxy disclosure regarding broad-based compensation policies, director qualifications, diversity, leadership structure, and compensation consultant additional fees; (ii) amend the proxy disclosure rules to record the value of stock awards in the Summary Compensation Table based on grant-date fair market value and to describe performance goals based on probable outcome of performance; (iii) require that the shareholder vote results be reported on Form 8-K (within four business days) rather than Form 10-K; and (iv) amend the proxy rules to provide that return of a blank proxy card is not a revocation, a soliciting person can round out its short slate by soliciting persons seeking minority representation on the board and certain other changes regarding proxy solicitation.
This summary discusses the amendments in (i) and (ii) above, which relate to director and executive compensation disclosure.
1. Narrative Disclosure of  Company’s Compensation Policies and Practices and How They Relate to the Company’s Risk Management.  Under prior proxy disclosure rules, the Compensation Discussion and Analysis (CD&A) section of the proxy needed to only discuss the compensation of the named executive officers (principal executive officer, principal financial officer, and the three other most highly compensated employees). Under the new 2009 amendments, the CD&A also has to discuss the company’s overall compensation policies for its employees in general even for nonexecutives, if the policies are reasonably likely to have a material adverse effect on the company.  New Item 402(s).
In particular, discussion and analysis would typically be required for compensation policies and practices at a particular business unit that carries a significant portion of the company’s risk profile, or where compensation of a business unit is structured significantly different than other units.  Id.
Issues that may need to be discussed in the CD&A include: (i) the design philosophy of compensation policies that would have the most effect on risk, (ii) considerations in structuring the compensation policies, (iii) how compensation policies relate to short-term risk, such as through clawbacks or mandatory bonus deferrals, and (iv) adjustments to compensation policies and practices that result from changes in risk profile; and (v) monitoring of compensation policies to determine if risk management objectives are being met with respect to incentivizing employees. Id.
Note:  Smaller reporting companies that do not need CD&As are also exempt from providing this additional disclosure.
Note:  This requirement to discuss the role of risk in compensation plans is intended to make compensation committee to consider how risk may play a role in incentive compensation, and to consider company-wide compensation plans, both of which have until now generally been considered outside the scope of compensation committees.
Note:  The above rules are a clear example of how the executive compensation proxy disclosure rules have moved beyond disclosure and into shaping compensation policy.
2. Expanded Disclosure about Directors, Nominees and Executive Officers (Whether or not up for Reelection).  The 2009 amendments expand the proxy rules to provide: (i) disclosure for directors, nominees and executive officers of their employment during the past five years, (ii) whether the entity they worked at is affiliated with the company, (iii) the directors and nominees’ experience or qualifications that led to the conclusion that the person is fit to serve on the board, (iv) if material, information about the director, nominee or executive’s areas of expertise and other relevant qualifications, (iv) disclosure of directorships of public companies in the past five years, and (v) for directors, nominees and officers, any prior business experience and level of responsibility within the past five years.  Amendment to Item 401(e).
Disclosure of any legal proceedings involving directors, nominees or executive officers is lengthened by the 2009 amendments from 5 to 10 years.  Item 401(f).  The amendments also require disclosure of additional legal proceedings, including proceedings resulting from wire or mail fraud or fraud in any business proceeding based on violations of securities, banking or insurance laws, and sanctions or orders imposed by a stock exchange.  Id.
3. Disclosure Regarding Company Leadership Structure and the Board’s Role in Risk Management Process.  Under the 2009 Amendments, Item 407 as well as the proxy rules require disclosure of the company leadership structure, such as whether the CEO also serves as chairman of the board, and whether there is a lead independent director, as well as why the company believes this is the best structure.  Amendment to S-K Item 407(h) and Item 7 of Schedule 14A.  Disclosure would also be required as to the extent of the board’s role in the company’s risk management, and the effect this has had on the leadership structure. Amendment to Item 407(h).
Note: Companies, as part of their corporate governance focus, have in any event begun to separate the CEO and chairman of the board roles.
4. Disclosure re Diversity.  The 2009 amendments require disclosure as to whether and how a nominating committee considers diversity in nominating directors, and whether the committee or the board has a policy on diversity.
5. Disclosure Regarding Compensation Consultants and Fees for Additional Services. The prior rules required disclosure of any role compensation consultants serve with respect to executive or director compensation, who hired the compensation consultants, the nature and scope of their assignment and the material elements of the directions given to the consultants. Item 407 was amended in 2009 to require fee disclosure for compensation consultants retained by the board in certain circumstances.  If the board or compensation committee has engaged a consultant to advise regarding executive and director compensation, and the consultant or its affiliates provide other consulting services in excess of $120,000, fees and related disclosure (such as whether decision to engage consultant for non-executive compensation was made or recommended by management and whether the board has approved the non-executive compensation consulting services) is required.  If management has engaged a consultant for executive compensation and non-executive compensation is in excess of $120,000 fee disclosure alone is required. Services involving any broad-based nondiscriminatory plans or information not customized for the company, are not executive compensation consulting and no fee disclosure is required.  Amendment to Item 407(e)(3)(iii).
Note: The above disclosure will enable investors to assess any incentives the consultants would have in recommending generous executive compensation, as stated in the Preamble.
Note: These disclosure requirements are aimed at avoiding a conflict of interest, and in that respect is similar to restrictions on non-audit services by independent auditors.
6. Reporting of Stock or Stock Option with Full Grant-Date Value in Summary Compensation Table.  Under prior December 2006 rules, the disclosure of stock awards and option-awards in the Summary Compensation Table and in the Director Compensation Table were determined based on the dollar amount recognized for financial reporting for the fiscal year.  Items 402(c)(2) and 402(v)(2), 71 Fed. Reg. 78,338 (Dec. 29, 2006). The 2009 amendments revert to the original method used by the regulations, which is to report stock awards and option awards in the compensation tables based on the full grant-date fair value in accordance with FASB ASC Topic 718 (formerly FAS 123R). 2009 amendment to Items 402(c)(2)(v) & (vi) and 402(k)(2)(iii) and (iv).  The amendments also eliminate the requirement of reporting grant-date fair value in the Grants of Plan-Based Awards Table or in the footnote to the Director Compensation Table because such amounts would already be provided for in the compensation tables.  Amendments to Items 402(d) and 402(k)(2).
Note: This 2009 amendment is in response to numerous comments received by the SEC that the grant-date fair value is more useful than the amount recognized in the financial statements for the fiscal year because investors consider the compensation decisions made during the fiscal year, (which would be the full grant-date fair values) in making voting and investment decisions. In addition, the prior method of using the dollar amount recognized for financial reporting for the fiscal year can result in an anomaly of reporting a negative number when the stock price drops.
Note: A proposal to rescind the requirement to report the full grant date face value of each equity award in the Grants of Plan-Based Awards and Director Compensation tables was withdrawn in the final 2009 rules.
Note: The final rules adapt the proposal to have the stock and option award to the past years in order to facilitate comparison in years.
Note: Disclosure of awards is made based on awards granted during the year, and not for the year to which the performance is based.  See Preamble to Final Rules, 74 Fed. Reg. 68339.
7. Salary or Bonus Foregone. There had been a proposal for salary and bonus columns in the Summary Compensation Table to not require reporting salary or bonus foregone at the election of the executive but the cash awards received instead or of salary or bonus would be reported in the column applicable to that form of award.  However, as noted in the Preamble to the final 2009 rules the SEC decided not to adopt this change.
Note: The Preamble to the 2009 rules notes that disclosing the amounts or salary or bonus that the Compensation Committee awarded better enables investors to understand salary and bonus.  See Instruction 2 to Item 402(c)(2)(iii) & (iv).
11. Disclosure of Target Performance Goals.  The final 2009 rules require that grant date fair value of performance awards be reported in the Summary Compensation, Grants of Plan-Based Awards and Director Compensation tables based on the probable outcome of the performance conditions, consistent with the recognition criteria in FASB ASC Topic 718.  The final 2009 rules do require footnote disclosure of the maximum value assuming the highest level of performance conditions is probable.  See Instruction 3 to Item 402(c)(2)(v) and (vi), and Instruction 3 to Item 402(n)(2)(v) and (vi).
Note:  This change was in response to comments that reporting the aggregate grant date fair value of performance awards based on maximum performance could discourage companies from granting these awards. As stated in the Preamble to the final 2009 rules, requiring disclosure of an award’s value to always be based on maximum performance would overstate the intended level of compensation and result in investor misinterpretation of compensation decisions.  Item 402(n)(2)(v) and (vi).
The amendments are effective February 28, 2010.
IRS Circular 230 Disclosure: To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the IRS, we inform you that any U.S. federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction or matter that is contained in this document.