Cryptocurrency
– An Imprudent 401(k) Investment?
Charles
C. Shulman, Esq.
Teaneck, NJ
201-357-0577
cshulman@ebeclaw.com
CAR No. 2022-01: Presumption of Imprudence on Cryptocurrency
for 401(k) Plans. On March 10, 2022, the Department
of Labor (“DOL”) issued Compliance Assistance Release (“CAR”)
No. 2022-01, cautioning plan fiduciaries to exercise extreme care before they
consider adding a “cryptocurrency” option to a 401(k) plan’s
investment menu for plan participants, and if they do add the cryptocurrency option,
they should be prepared for a possible DOL investigation. CAR No. 2022-01 noted
that when a 401(k) plan offers a menu of investment options to plan
participants, the responsible fiduciaries have an obligation to ensure the
prudence of “each” options on an ongoing basis.[1]
CAR No. 2022-01 cited the recent Supreme
Court case of Hughes v. Northwestern University, 142 S.Ct. 737, 742
(2022), which held that even in a participant directed plan where participants
choose their investments, plan fiduciaries are required to conduct their own
independent evaluation to determine whether “each” investment should be
prudently included in the plan’s menu of options.
CAR No. 2022-01 states that in this early stage in the
history of cryptocurrencies, the DOL has serious concerns about the prudence of
a fiduciary’s decision to expose 401(k) plan participants to direct investments
in cryptocurrencies, or other products whose value is tied to cryptocurrencies,
as these are speculative and volatile investments and they present significant
risks and challenges to participants’ retirement accounts, including
significant risks of fraud, theft, and loss, and also raise custodial and
recordkeeping concerns.
DOL Expecting to Investigate Plans that Offer
Cryptocurrency – CAR No. 2022-01 noted that
the DOL expects to conduct an investigative program aimed at plans that offer
participant investments in cryptocurrencies and related products, and to take
appropriate action to protect the interests of plan participants and
beneficiaries with respect to these investments. Plan fiduciaries responsible
for overseeing such investment options or allowing such investments through “brokerage
windows” should expect to be questioned about how they can square their
actions with their duties of prudence and loyalty in light of the risks
described above, according to CAR No. 2022-01.[2]
Fidelity April 2022 Introduction of a Bitcoin Fund in
its Core Lineup of 401(k) Investments – Less
than two months after the issuance of CAR No. 2022-01, on April 26, 2022
Fidelity Investments announced that it is adding a digital asset fund holding Bitcoin
to their core investment lineup for 401(k) funds (although it had been
available under its brokerage account for a number of years), and if agreed to
by employers for their individual plans, participants will be able to invest up
to 20 percent or more of their 401(k) contributions in the Bitcoin fund. This
is certainly not congruous with CAR No. 2022-01. However, a DOL official
commented on May 23, 2022 that in his view retirement plans that are clients of financial institutions marketing
cryptocurrency products will not automatically
be subjected to a Department of Labor audit. Reported in Bloomberg Daily Labor Report (May 24, 2022).
Lawsuit Alleging DOL Had no Authority to Issue These
New Rules without Administrative Rulemaking and Review – On June 2, 2022, the DOL was sued by ForUsAll, Inc.,
which was the first 401(k) platform to provide access to cryptocurrency, in the
District Court in Washington, D.C., alleging that the DOL violated the
Administrative Procedure Act by issuing new fiduciary rules in CAR No. 2022-01 without
following the correct procedures.[3]
Perhaps in response to this litigation and other pushback on CAR No. 2022-01, DOL
Secretary Marty Walsh told a House panel on June 14, 2022 that the DOL is
looking at potentially going through a rulemaking process on the cryptocurrency
industry as a whole. See Bloomberg Daily Labor Report, June 15, 2022.
Surprises in CAR No. 2021 – CAR No. 2022-01 surprised many practitioners for a
number of reasons: (i) CAR No.
2022-01 appears extreme in labeling a cryptocurrency fund from amongst other diverse
401(k) funds as having a presumption of “imprudence;” even if cryptocurrency
is volatile and speculative, that contributes not only on the downside but also
on the upside; (ii) one
would have expected that offering, e.g., a Bitcoin fund as part of a wide
variety of diversified funds, and limiting the Bitcoin fund to for example not
more than 20% of the account balance, as Fidelity did, should NOT be deemed to
be imprudent as a rule or giving rise to an audit for that reason alone; (iii) CAR No.
2022-01 also stated that fiduciaries allowing cryptocurrencies in 401(k) plans even
if just though “brokerage windows” should expect to be questioned
about how they can square their actions with their ERISA fiduciary duties. Many
practitioners were surprised with this added statement, because brokerage
windows (which have been around for at least 20 years)[4]
have been and continue to be offered in many 401(k) plans, and fiduciaries cannot
possibly evaluate each trade in the brokerage accounts.[5]
If you have any questions on this or any other matters, please call me know at 201-357-0577.
Charlie
[1] DOL EBSA
Compliance Assistance Release No. 2022-01 – 401(k) Plan Investments in
“Cryptocurrencies” (March 10, 2022), https://tinyurl.com/DOL-2022-01.
[2] DOL EBSA
Compliance Assistance Release No. 2022-01.
[3] ForUsAll, Inc. v U.S. Department of
Labor and Martin J Walsh Secretary of Labor Complaint, filed with U.S. Dist.
Ct. for D.C. (June 2, 2022),
resources.forusall.com/Dkt.%20001%20ForUsAll%20Complaint.pdf
[4] Field
Assistance Bulletin No. 2012-02R (July 30, 2012) in FAB No. 39 notes that the
DOL does not prohibit the use of a platform or a brokerage window,
self-directed brokerage account, or similar plan arrangement in an individual
account plan. In 2014 the DOL solicited comments regarding standards for
brokerage windows in participant directed account plans, although no regulations
were issued to date. On occasion, an employer might have to file a Form S-8
registration statement for employer stock if the stock may be purchased by
401(k) plan participants through a brokerage account window.
[5]
It is true, though, that some plans
have shied away from brokerage windows because of the increased investment risk and the inability to monitor the
investments.

