State-Mandated Retirement Savings Programs
– Latest Updates
By Charles C. Shulman, Esq.
cshulman@ebeclaw.com
201.357.0577
I. Background,
DOL Interpretive Bulletin 2015-02
A.
State Mandated Retirement Savings Programs Enacted in a Number of States. In the past 10 years, a number of states have
enacted laws requiring private employers to facilitate a state-mandated retirement
savings arrangement if they don’t already offer one. The most common model is
the payroll-deduction auto-IRA (generally a Roth IRA). These are usually
structured as a Roth IRA. Most of these programs default to an initial
contribution rate set between 3% and 5%. Employers can remain exempt if they
choose to establish their own private retirement plans like a 401(k).
B.
Interpretive Bulletin 2015-02.
The Department of Labor set forth guidance in 2015 that enabled state-mandated
retirement savings programs. DOL Interpretive Bulletin 2015-02, DOL Reg. § 2509.2015-02, 80 Fed. Reg. 71936 (Nov. 18,
2015), provide guidance on how states can
sponsor or facilitate retirement programs without violating ERISA preemption.
It notes that states act as market participants when they offer voluntary
options. These models include (i) marketplace platforms to connect businesses
with private plans and payroll deduction IRAs, (ii) state-sponsored prototype
plans, or (iii) multiple employer plans where the state serves as the lead
sponsor. Such programs are generally permitted if participation is voluntary
and they don’t interfere with the uniform administration of private benefit
plans. The bulletin explicitly distinguishes these ERISA-covered models from
the auto-IRA models that many states now mandate.
II. States With
Mandated Retirement Savings Programs
A.
17 States with Enacted Mandatory Auto-IRA Programs. Currently, there are at least seventeen
states with active or upcoming mandatory auto-IRA programs for covered
employers. These states include California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware,
Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, New York,
Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia and Washington State. Philadelphia is the first city to enact (in May 2026) a
mandatory auto-IRA program for private-sector workers.
B.
Most of the 17 States Use Just a Roth IRA; Employee Threshold Between 1 and 25.
The auto-IRA is generally a Roth IRA, although
several states, including California & NJ, also allow a traditional IRA
option. The employee threshold is generally 1, 5 or 10 employees (in Virginia,
25 employees). In NYS, affiliated employers under IRC § 414 are aggregated.
C. In 17 States, Initial
Deferral Between 3% and 5% and Some have Auto-Escalation. In most of
the states the initial contribution is 5%, but in some, e.g., CT, NJ & NY
it is 3%. Most contain an annual 1% escalation up to 8 or 10%.
D.
States with Voluntary IRA Programs.
New Mexico has a voluntary IRA and Roth IRA program. Mississippi
and Utah enacted voluntary IRA programs in 2026. Pennsylvania and Georgia
are considering auto-IRA programs.
E.
States with 401(k) MEP. Massachusetts
has a voluntary 401(k) multiple employer plan (MEP) for small nonprofits , and
Missouri is launching a voluntary 401(k) MEP for businesses with 50 or fewer
employees.
F.
States With No Mandatory Retirement Savings Program. The remaining states, e.g., Texas, Florida, Ohio,
either have no active mandates or have only recently begun considering
legislation without passing laws.
G.
No Employer Contribution; Same Limit as Individual IRAs. The state mandated or voluntary savings
programs prohibit employer matching or non-elective contributions. The annual
contribution limit for the state IRAs or Roth IRAs in 2026 is $7,500 for
individuals under age 50, and $8,600 for those 50 or older.
H. Exemption for Partial Qualified Plan
Coverage. An employer doesn’t need to cover all workers
to be exempt from these mandates. The exemption for sponsoring a qualified plan
applies even if it covers some, but not all, employees. Official guidance in
California, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Minnesota, New Jersey and New
York specifically confirms this partial coverage rule. Minnesota and New Jersey
explicitly note this includes employers who merely contribute to a
multiemployer trust fund for union employees. Commentators assume that the
other states with mandatory auto-IRA programs also operate under the same
entity-level structure exemption for maintaining or contributing to qualified
plan for some employees and would also exempt employers that contribute to
multiemployer plans to which the employer contributes to.
I.
IRAs are Portable; Distribution Age.
These accounts are fully portable. Employees keep their savings and can
transfer the accounts even if they change jobs. Funds can be rolled into other
IRAs. However, IRS regulations do not permit rolling Roth IRA funds into an
employer-sponsored 401(k). Participants can withdraw their Roth IRA including investment
earnings tax-free and penalty-free at age 59 1/2 and after a five-year holding period.
To withdraw non-Roth amounts without the 10% early distribution penalty, the
participant generally must be at least age 59 1/2. The participant will still
be subject to ordinary income tax on the distribution of these non-Roth
amounts.
III. New York
Secure Choice Savings Program
A.
New York Secure Choice Savings Program with Roth IRAs for Employers With 10 or
More Employees that do Not Otherwise Participate in a Qualified Retirement
Plan. New York State initially enacted its NYS
Secure Choice Savings Program in 2018 as a voluntary option for employers with
under 100 employees. New York later amended the law in October 2021 to make
participation mandatory for covered employers. Following several implementation
delays, the program officially launched in October 2025. An employer is a covered
employer in New York if the employer (i) employed 10 or more workers in the
state at all times during the previous calendar year, (ii) has been in business
for at least two years, and (iii) hasn’t offered a qualified retirement plan in
the preceding two years. An employer should formally certify its exemption on
the state portal at https://www.newyorksecurechoice.com if it already sponsors
a qualified plan.
B.
Roth IRA Only; 3% Deferral Rate; No Auto-Escalation. For New York only the Roth IRA is available.
The initial contribution is 3% of total pay. There is no auto-escalation, although
employees may elect an annual escalation or higher contribution percentages up
to 10%. Employees can opt out or choose different elections at any time. Employers
cannot make matching contributions and cannot contribute to the plans.
C.
Under the New York Secure Choice Savings Program, the 10 Employee Threshold
Would Also Include Controlled Group Affiliates of the Employer. New
York General Business Law, Article 43, Section 1300, regarding the NYS Secure
Choice Savings Program, defined “employer” as an entity with 10 or
more employees engaged in a business, industry, profession, trade, or other
enterprise in New York state, whether for profit or not for profit. Section 1300 also provides that all terms
carry the same meaning as used in comparable contexts in the Internal Revenue
Code. It is generally assumed that this will include the controlled group rules
of IRC §§ 414(b) and (c) and the affiliated service group rules of IRC §
414(m). Other states do not specifically incorporate controlled group aggregation
rules.
D. If Qualified Plan Offered Only to Part of
Workforce Such as Union Employees. New York
General Business Law Article 43, Section 1300(4) provides an exception from NYS
Secure Choice mandate the employer has “offered a qualified retirement plan,
including, but not limited to, a plan qualified undersections 401(a), 401(k),
403(a), 403(b), 408(k), 408(p) or 457(b) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986
in the preceding two years. See also, https://newyorksecurechoice.zendesk.com/hc/en-us
with details on this.
The
NYS Secure Choice Savings Program Employer FAQs – at
https://newyorksecurechoice.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/31467718990615 –
answers the question: “I already offer a 401(k) or other
qualified retirement plan to some employees but not all. Do I have to offer
this program too?” And the answer
given is “No, if you offer an employer-sponsored retirement plan to any
of your employees, you can certify your exemption, and you will not need to
facilitate the program.” Commentators
assume that the same should be true if the employer contributed to a
multiemployer pension or 401(k) plan for only the union employees and nonunion
employees were not covered by a plan.
E.
Portability and Investments.
The NYS Secure Choice Roth IRA is fully portable from employer to employer. New
York initially places funds in a Conservative Principal Protection Fund for 30
days. It then moves the funds to a Target Retirement Date Fund based on an
assumed retirement age of 65, unless another fund is selected by the employee.
F.
New York Enrollment Deadlines – the Latest is July 15, 2026. New York enrollment deadlines are: for employers
with 30 or more employees, March 18, 2026; for employers with 15 to 29 employees, May 15,
2026; and for employers with 10 to 14 employees, July 15, 2026.
G.
Potential Penalties in NYS. In NYS,
lack of compliance with the NYS Secure Choice Savings Program mandates, triggers
a warning in the first year, and could reach (i) $250 per employee in the
second year, (ii) $500 in the third year, and (iii) $1,000 per employee in
subsequent years. Specific failure-to-register penalties may still be under
review.
IV. NJ Secure
Choice Savings Program – RetireReady NJ
A.
RetireReady NJ Program – Threshold Lowered to 10 Employees in Jan. 2026. New Jersey enacted its Secure Choice Savings
Program Act on March 28, 2019, codified in N.J.S.A. 43:23-13 through 32. It was
amended on January 20, 2026. NJ P.L. 2025, c. 379. The NJ program launched on
June 30, 2024. NJ Secure Choice Savings Program was rebranded as RetireReady NJ
prior to the launching. The mandate originally covered employers with 25 or
more employees.
B. Enrollment Deadline in NJ for 25+
Employees Was in Nov. 2024, Future Deadline for 10+ Employees TBD. The
registration deadline for employers with 25 or more employees passed on
November 15, 2024. The January 2026 amendment reduced the employer threshold in
NJ from 25 to 10 employees. Once implemented, employers with 10 or more workers
will be required to participate if they have operated for two years and lack a
qualified plan. The employer should formally certify its exemption on the state
portal at retireready.nj.gov if it already sponsors a qualified plan. New
Jersey does not incorporate controlled group rules, and an entity-by-entity
determination can be made.
C.
Default Roth IRA at 3% With Auto-Escalation.
Employers cannot make matching contributions and cannot contribute to the
plans. New Jersey savers may choose either a Roth or a traditional IRA, though
the Roth IRA is the default option. NJ sets a default employee contribution
rate of 3% of gross pay, but the 3% initial rate automatically escalates by 1%
each January until it reaches a 10% cap. Employees can opt out entirely at any
time.
D. Exemption for Offering of a Qualified Plan
Just to Union Employees Or Just to Some of Employees? New Jersey
RetireReady exempts employers that already offer their own retirement savings
plan, as stated in
https://retirereadynj.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/22909195207831. The NJ
webinar FAQs at https://www.nj.gov/treasury/securechoiceprogram/documents/pdf/webinar-answers.pdf
states that (i) an employer is entirely exempt if they offer an
employer-sponsored plan to any portion of their workforce, (ii) contributing to
a union retirement plan exclusively for union members satisfies this
requirement, and (iii) the employer isn’t required to be the primary plan
sponsor or offer the plan to all employee..
E.
Portability; Target Date Funds; Withdrawals.
RetireReady NJ accounts are fully portable from employer to employer. New
Jersey relies primarily on various targeted market-based investments similar to
target date funds. You can roll the funds into another IRA. However, IRS rules
generally don’t permit rolling Roth IRA funds into an employer 401(k).
Participants can generally withdraw their own IRA or Roth IRA contributions at
any time without tax or penalty. Withdrawing investment earnings usually
requires a qualified distribution. To avoid income tax and a 10% additional
tax, the participant generally must be at least age 59 1/2 and have held the
account for a five-year period.
F.
NJ Penalties. New Jersey
issues a written warning in the first year of noncompliance. It then fines
employers (i) $100 per employee in the second year, (ii) $250 in the third and
fourth years, and (iii) $500 from the fifth year onward.
[1] Charles C. Shulman, Esq., Teaneck,
New Jersey, cshulman@ebeclaw.com, 201-357-0577, has extensive experience in
employee benefits and executive compensation law, including drafting,
negotiating and advising on qualified plans, ERISA liability, nonqualified plans,
executive compensation, equity-based awards, health, welfare and fringe benefit
plans, employment agreements, fiduciary issues, employment law matters, and
related M&A work. He is the author of numerous articles on a variety of
employee benefit & executive compensation topics, including the seminal
chapter “Employee Benefits and Executive Compensation in Mergers &
Acquisitions,” and the west treatise “Qualified Retirement Plans.” He is
admitted to the N.Y. and N.J. bars, inducted as a fellow in the American
College of Employee Benefits Counsel and a Contributing Editor of the WK
Journal of Pension Planning & Compliance and the Journal of Deferred
Compensation. He holds a J.D. & LL.M from N.Y.U. School of Law.
Addendum: New York and New Jersey Enrollment Deadlines 11-17-26
New Jersey—New deadlines for employers with 10–24 employees. Following the January 2026 expansion of RetireReady NJ to employers with 10 or more employees, New Jersey announced two additional enrollment deadlines: December 1, 2026, for employers with 20–24 employees, and February 17, 2027, for employers with 10–19 employees. These deadlines are confirmed by the New Jersey Secure Choice Savings Board’s September 2026 employer guidance. Employers that already offer a qualified retirement plan remain exempt but should certify their exemption through the RetireReady NJ portal.
New York—Additional enrollment deadline. The initial New York Secure Choice enrollment deadlines for employers with 10 or more employees expired between March and July 2026. The program has announced a further deadline of November 18, 2026, for newly eligible employers. Employers that already offer a qualified retirement plan may certify their exemption through the New York Secure Choice portal.
Both programs continue to require covered employers to facilitate employee payroll-deduction IRAs rather than establish employer-funded retirement plans.